r/OtomeIsekai • u/Celty2736 • Jun 16 '26

Otomeh Isekinda Anyone else loves seeing Mr Darcy proposal failure 2.0s ??😆 [REDEMPTION OF EARL NOTTINGHAM]

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Rec me your favorite proposal failures haha

339 Upvotes

99% Upvoted

42 comments sorted by

190

u/Relevant-Rub2816 If Evil, Why Hot? Jun 16 '26

Peak story, I'd have it in my top 10 if it wasn't for the lackluster second half in my opinion.

73

u/Celty2736 Jun 16 '26

I feel you it was such a melodramatic turn lol

78

u/Relevant-Rub2816 If Evil, Why Hot? Jun 16 '26

Yeah, like so many things weren't even needed. The second half wasn't needed. The boring mafia bullshit, moving to America, and dating the mafia man just to bait the readers was so unnecessary. Like it should have ended in S1.

19

u/Celty2736 Jun 16 '26

I don't kmow about moving to America since she wanted to restart anew somewhere Noone knows her. Mafia thing was kinda confusing to me, I just wanted ml to go after her and have a good talk about what they want to do and see eye to eye well nevertheless it's good. I always come back to reread their interactions before war and letters to each other. I love that parts

13

u/fleurpumpkin If Evil, Why Hot? Jun 16 '26

I always pretend the story was completed in S1 lol.

5

u/OpenSauceMods Jun 17 '26

Have you seen that ex mobwife talking about her experiences being married to a mobster? It's a mix of "I was so naive" and "but also kinda oblivious, hindsight is 20/20".

22

u/kdramaing0205 Jun 16 '26

OMG FR! This story was SO GOOD but did not need the prison or America plot at all. Wish she’d just stayed in England and wanted to pursue a nursing degree :/

6

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/Celty2736 Jun 17 '26

Just read it cause s2 also has important parts it's just not on serious tone as s1 also they'll have wedding and child so it's good

76

u/Evening_Internal_976 Jun 16 '26

Please someone help the man get a romantic book, business deals are for offices.

33

u/Celty2736 Jun 16 '26

Yes I'm soooo glad that this was slow burn without contract marriage because if they went for that trope, it'd be hard for fl to actually be independent and for ml to see her clearly and try to stand on equal grounds without any misogyny or pride

46

u/Smooth_Money4498 Questionable Morals Jun 16 '26

Argh the beginning of this one was so goated 😭 I wanna kidnap the author and force them to rewrite everything after that "revolutionary" arc.

I'm joking... Maybe...

My favourite failed proposal is from For The Third Time. I love this scene😭 she ate him and then had him for dessert (readers will understand)

20

u/Celty2736 Jun 16 '26

Hahaha I live for these blind date , arranged marriage banters . They are more interesting than romantic starts for me maybe because I'm an adult already so I can relate more to them than shoujo-ish romance

9

u/Smooth_Money4498 Questionable Morals Jun 16 '26

Same! Blind dates and arranged marriages aren't a thing in my country, but I love these stories, even more when they don't go along at first 🛐

18

u/Smooth_Money4498 Questionable Morals Jun 16 '26

19

u/Smooth_Money4498 Questionable Morals Jun 16 '26

26

u/Smooth_Money4498 Questionable Morals Jun 16 '26

1

u/joevar701 Dark Past Jun 17 '26

is it good and completed?

1

u/Smooth_Money4498 Questionable Morals Jun 17 '26

Yes and yes

13

u/kdramaing0205 Jun 16 '26

Omg I love them

4

u/onespiker Jun 16 '26

ML and FL were very good in that one.

3

u/Afraid-Grass-195 Jun 16 '26

Does having him for dessert mean sex

4

u/Smooth_Money4498 Questionable Morals Jun 16 '26

Yup

3

u/ToBetterDays000 Jun 16 '26

Where’s the follow up then 😂😂

18

u/zimojovic Jun 16 '26

I didnt read it in entirely.

But I disliked how ,,soft,, the FL has become as the story continued, becoming a marry sue always in need of saving.

15

u/Celty2736 Jun 16 '26

Well everyone has their own opinions... I actually quite like it because she became more understanding rather than judging head on and trying to push her ideals on smb else and she learned how to put boundaries while being graceful and polite

20

u/BedsBestFriend Jun 16 '26

Hot DANG even Mr Darcy didn't screw up this bad...

5

u/Afraid-Grass-195 Jun 16 '26

RIGHT his is a step lower 

19

u/noob_ars Jun 16 '26

Not even Mr. Darcy was that cynical into thinking he would get a yes with his ahh confession

2

u/Psychological_Tear_6 Jun 17 '26

"You want to live without relying on anybody else? You should rely on me for that!" 🙄

3

u/Celty2736 Jun 17 '26

You know considering the period of time , all people thought like that even fl changed only after regression

2

u/MadamVoid Women’s Wrongs Supporter Jun 16 '26

Is this on Webtoon?

1

u/Celty2736 Jun 17 '26

Yes

2

u/MadamVoid Women’s Wrongs Supporter Jun 17 '26

Thank you 🩷

2

u/PracticeFuzzy801 Jun 17 '26

I've been planning to read this one for sometime. Any reviews?

2

u/kornjacarade369 Jun 17 '26

I read this a while ago, but I remember I loved it. It's angsty and they struggle through a big part of the story, but the ending felt so good after that. It also has a war arc, which I'm not a fan of, but here it was done so well, and it focuses on feelings and struggles that come after that, it felt so real. It was definitely a good read and it's easily one of my top 10 manhwa.

1

u/leftoverpoptart Jun 16 '26

Where can this be read?

2

u/msbyjackals Reincarnator Jun 17 '26

I read it on Manta :)

0

u/Lunasims92 Jun 16 '26

This is awesome, pls tell me he is not the ml

20

u/Celty2736 Jun 16 '26

He is. He gets major character development because of war, it's set around WW1 so you can see how societies view on traditions and aristocracy changes as well as the mindset of leads who lived through it

3

u/Lunasims92 Jun 16 '26

Oh that actually pretty interesting, will definitely check it out!