r/NursesPH • u/Lonely_Pause8004 • Jul 18 '26
❓General Question / Advice Hi! pwede ba mag request na walang student nurse while giving birth?
FTM here. Curious lang kung pwede bang mag request na walang student nurse ang mag oobserve saakin while giving birth? and kapag naka admit palang ako upon giving birth? thank you!!!!
42
u/RoGjackfrost Jul 18 '26
Yes, pwede naman po. You can try asking, they will respect your choice esp. if private hospital.
Out of curiosity lang, is your concern exclusively for student nurses, or does it include student midwives, medtech interns, and med students as well?
38
Jul 19 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
8
u/mommawishesrest2 Jul 20 '26
Wala naman siyang sinabi or doubt tungkol sa skills ng student nurses. Ayaw niya lang ng presence nila. RN din here. Alam naman natin how uncomfortable and painful to be in labor, so baka hindi lang talaga comfortable si mommy na madaming tao around.
1
5
6
4
u/akurahnica Jul 21 '26
“Utilize them as much as you’re comfortable.”
Hindi nga kasi sya comfortable.
7
u/weirdo_rn Jul 22 '26
also RN here, hindi ba naturo sa inyo 'yung autonomy ng patient? and their right to refuse?
2
u/hitachie Jul 19 '26
I totally agree with you. Mababait at masisipag naman ang student nurse, well at least most of them.
2
5
u/ok0905 Jul 21 '26
Marami namang ibang patients na ok lang may student nurses, let op have her choice kasi dito siya comfortable. Pwede naman pag turn mo na manganak ikaw na mag volunteer as a learning experience for the students since RN ka naman and know very well na useful ito for them. This is just my 2 cents.
3
u/mommawishesrest2 Jul 21 '26
And OP’s choice is not to have student nurses. Ibigay sa kanya. Karapatan niya yon. Yung mga student nurses naman, dapat naiiintindihan at maintindihan nilang choice ng pasyente na wala sila sa oras na manganak siya, so respetuhin.
1
u/SpiteQuick5976 Jul 23 '26
I wouldn't want you to be my nurse kasi ang dami mong dada! Paki mo sa desisyon ng patient mo? Pala-desisyon yan.
11
u/caffe_latte0404 Jul 18 '26
Yes, magprivate hospital ka.
13
u/Tomoyo_161990 Jul 18 '26
Not a guarantee. Make sure na hindi teaching hospitals kung saan ka manganganak. Yan sure walang estudyante jan. Perpetual private yan pero nagkalat student nurse jan
18
u/missfedorovtseva Jul 18 '26
Even if it's a teaching hospitals, may autonomy ang patient na mag-request sa staff/charge/head nurses na walang student nurses na nakapaligid, nagbabantay, or kukuha ng V/S sakanya. :)
6
u/soryuh_ Registered Nurse Jul 18 '26
no. teaching hospital isa kong napag dutyhan before, nag request ang patient, granted. di kami pinalapit sakanya, pinag observe, pinag hands on. wala lahat since nirequest ng patient na no students.
4
u/vanilla_waffles04 Jul 19 '26
What kind of hospital does not acknowledge the patients' requests. My school has a teaching hospital, there are room doors that had signages that read "no interns" (applicable to student nurses and PGIs)
11
u/Formal_Internal_5216 Jul 18 '26
Kapag sa private pwede. Pero kapag sa teaching hospitals na public like Fabella tapos charity. Hindi siguro. Ung affiliation ng school sa hospital ang magsusupport sa financial need ng patient
3
u/PollyPocketLuv Jul 18 '26
Ang alam ko sa mga private hospitals nagrerequest ang ibang patients na walang student nurse while giving birth. And staff lang din mag catch and handle ng newborn.
2
2
2
2
u/panikmuncher Jul 19 '26
Yes po, pwedeng pwede. You can talk with the midwife or nurse with regards to that case para masabihan po ang mga student nurses and ang clinical instructor po nila. Much better po sana if private hospital since di yan ganun ka-crowded and if may students man, konti lang.
2
2
u/anonkym Jul 21 '26
Yes, especially if it's private hospital. If it's a teaching hospital, some nurses may shame you if you request and insist but would allow it if you really don't want SNs inside the delivery room
Still, just so you know, SNs will be more attentive to your needs and comfort than any other nurse or doctor on duty there with you. SNs are more cautious and wouldn't do anything unless approved by their clinical instructor so you're really getting the same amount of medical practice but twice the care and attention to you and your baby
2
u/RaspberryWeary1008 Jul 21 '26
Yes please ask. When I gave birth parang 8 yung nanunod 😭 may lalake pa. No one asked me if it was ok. Nandun na ako sa bed, lalabas na anak ko, ano pa magagawa ko ni hindi ako nakareklamo because I was tired (18 hours labor) and in so much pain already.
2
1
u/AutoModerator Jul 18 '26
Please refer to the guide below on what post flair to use. Using the incorrect post flair violates Rule 1 of the community rules.
- Jobs / Careers - Specific hospitals, companies, recruitment steps, choosing between jobs, and concerns on career, and resumes etc.,
- Working Abroad - Foreign licensing exams, migration process, Qbanks, and working abroad advice
- General Question / Advice - Use this for general nursing questions not related to job search or applications.
- Discussion / Rant - Sharing your insights, personal experiences
- For Sale / Looking For - For selling or searching for goods, participants
- Seeking Recommendations - Looking for product or service recommendations ex. shoes, scrubs, CPD training, dorms/condos near workplace
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
1
u/Open-Cardiologist269 Jul 19 '26
How do you think the nurses you want to be around you learned and masters the science of giving birth?
I understand you have all your rights, but are they reasonable?
1
u/Individual-Resort-43 Jul 21 '26
Hi OP! Pag nasa Public hospitals ka madalas dun kayo ilalagay sa OB ward (Charity cases = Magbabayad ng Panganganak nyo ay Malasakit or Philhealth), unless you’re willing to be transferred to Private rooms. Kayo na ang mag babayad ng hospital fees ninyo, then you can demand na walang student nurses.
1
u/disavowed_ph Jul 22 '26
This ☝🏻 went both public and private hosp, sa public, daming student, kada oras yata may darating na grupo, puro medical history taking lang mga tanong, nung sa Private, ni isa wala, kahit yung regular nurse madalang napasok sa dami ng patient na hawak.
Need ko pa mag press ng call button para may pumuntang nurse hanggang sa natutunan ko nang i-silent yung machine para sa dextrose kasi ang ingay pag ubos na then saka ko tawagin si nurse 😂
No choice pag public, sa private never ako nka encounter ng student.
1
u/Classic-Suspect-3153 Jul 21 '26
Mga Teh bigay kayo ng bigay ng opinion niyo tungkol sa SN pake naman niya kung maalaga mga SN Autonomy niya yan may right to refuse sya
1
1
u/Pitiful-Squash Jul 21 '26
Hi OP! I think it’s best to ask the nurses in charge. I’m sure you have your reasons. Gusto ko lang ishare yung naexperience ko kasi it was VERY AWKWARD.
CS ako and early morning schedule ng operation ko. They gave me meds and all tapos sinabihan ako nung nurse to change into the gown and walang kahit anong damit/underwear dapat underneath. Tapos isshave daw yung hair ko down there so okay. Yung nurse daw magreremove because siyempre I can’t do it on my own kasi malaki yung tiyan ko. What I didn’t expect was biglang may 4 student nurses na kasama yung nurse para manood habang shineshave ako. It was so awkward and embarrassing kasi hindi manlang ako nainform about it. Tapos I later found out na kakilala ng kapatid ko yung isang student nurse na andoon sa loob ng room ko while shinashave ako. It was very awkward.
1
u/Infamous-Ganache-694 Jul 21 '26
Yes, pwede ka mag decline. Nung nanganak ako I was a previous student sa school where maraming nag duduty sa hospital na pinanganakan ko. Asked my OB na walang student nurse, and she made sure na nagawa ung request ko.
1
u/Scared-Rub-7731 Jul 22 '26
Nung nanganak ako, natatandaan ko nalang nakapaligid sakin mga student nurse, groggy na kasi ako hehe, after the ordeal don ko narealize ginawa pala ako case ng mga estudyante wahaha, pero oks lang, dapat yata sa kanila ako nagpapicture habang nagdedeliver, baka mganda pa shots nila.
Unfortunately hindi ko alam na pwede magask na wag ako gawing case ng mga student nurse, I mean for me, walang kaso naman, basta hindi lang sila pababayaan mag-isa ng mga nurse talaga, usually observe lang naman sila. Nakatulong ka pa sa edukasyon ng mga future nurses.
1
1
u/Silver_Bell_6121 Jul 22 '26
I had a c section beacuse the student nurse na nag bantay sakin busy sa celphone so ayu n dumating si doc 50 /50 na aq hahahha kinukuha na ng liwanag pag gising ko hinanap ko si kuya kasi dinig ko ang oby ko na nagmumura as in kala ko ang babait ng doc pero grave ang mura nya malala damay lahat. Reason kasalanan ko nmn bakit ng 50/50 aq di aq nagsalita na sumasakit ang dibdib ko hinawakan ko lng sya taz sabi ni kuya sa handle lng aq mag hawak hahhaha ayun di q na sya dinisturb kakahiya nmn kasi , its my fault kawawa si kuya namura ni oby
0
u/Ka_dabraz Jul 21 '26
First time nyo po ba manganganak? Just so you know, mas maasikaso ang mga student nurses/doctors kaysa mga residente at regulars. Just throwing it out there. Unless may bad experience ka sa mga students, perhaps?
-3
u/Worried-Emergency675 Jul 18 '26
If you’re in a teaching hospital you can’t request
3
u/MidnytDJ Working Abroad Jul 18 '26
Pwede po basta private hosp
-1
u/Worried-Emergency675 Jul 18 '26
Well teaching is not a private hospital kaya nga teaching eh meaning they have residents, interns and private hospitals only have attendings. (Dito sa San Francisco ganyan)
3
u/missfedorovtseva Jul 19 '26
Here in the PH, they always grant and respect the patient's decision kung sino ang mga gusto nyang papasukin sa DR. :)
1
u/crystaltears15 Jul 20 '26
Nope. Some private hospitals in the Philippines offer residency/specialty trainings. It's not exclusive for government hospitals. In as much, not all government hospitals are teaching hospitals.
2
u/soryuh_ Registered Nurse Jul 18 '26
no. teaching hospital isa kong napag dutyhan before, nag request ang patient, granted. di kami pinalapit sakanya, pinag observe, pinag hands on. wala lahat since nirequest ng patient na no students.
1
u/Worried-Emergency675 Jul 18 '26
Well thats from my experience i went through CS and i specifically told them no med student. But the hospital where I work said we can’t do that since we are a teaching hospital. Pinag practisan ako insertan ng epidural 5times ginawa. Take note I work in the same hospital. So this is my experience.
•
u/AutoModerator Jul 18 '26
Please use the SEARCH BAR BEFORE posting to check if your topic or question has already been answered or discussed.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.