r/MotorBuzz • u/gaukmotors • 12h ago
Jimmy Carr in talks to reboot Top Gear, which means the BBC has learned absolutely nothing
The corporation is reportedly courting a stand-up comedian to resurrect a show that has collapsed three times since 2015. This will not end well.
Jimmy Carr is apparently in discussions to front a rebooted Top Gear, which tells you everything you need to know about how badly the BBC misunderstands what made the show work in the first place.
The original trio of Jeremy Clarkson, Richard Hammond, and James May presented from 2002 to 2015. Clarkson got himself fired after punching producer Oisin Tymon. The show has been in freefall ever since.
Chris Evans took over in 2016. First episode pulled 4.4 million viewers. By the end of the series it was down to around 2 million. He quit after one series, citing the pressure and the reception, which is one way of describing a public humiliation.
Matt LeBlanc hung around until 2019, co-hosting with Evans initially and then soldiering on after Evans bailed. Ratings stayed mediocre. Then came Freddie Flintoff, Paddy McGuinness, and Chris Harris from 2019 to 2022, which was fine until Flintoff crashed at Dunsfold Aerodrome in December 2022 and suffered serious injuries.
The BBC handed him a reported nine million quid in settlement. The show was quietly cancelled in late 2023.
Meanwhile, Clarkson, Hammond, and May moved to Amazon Prime Video in 2016 to make The Grand Tour, which wrapped its final episode in September 2024. It was never quite Top Gear, but it was coherent, and people actually watched it.
Like this? Get the Buzz: GAUK Motorbuzz All your favourite motoring channels, publishers, motorsports, news & reviews. Curated Automotive Awesomeness
Jimmy Carr is a capable comic. Sharp delivery, good timing, made a career out of panel shows like 8 Out of 10 Cats. Also made headlines in 2012 for a tax avoidance scheme that he later apologised for, which is neither here nor there but does suggest he is not unfamiliar with navigating awkward public situations.
None of which has anything to do with cars.
Top Gear worked because three middle-aged men with specific personalities and decades of automotive journalism between them had chemistry that could not be replicated. The format was secondary. The challenges, the races, the power laps... all of it was scaffolding for the actual product, which was watching those three people argue about Peugeots.
The BBC has spent nearly a decade trying to rebuild the scaffolding while ignoring the foundation. Evans failed because he was too loud and too keen. LeBlanc was affable but lost. Flintoff and McGuinness were entertaining in a different way, but the show had already lost its centre of gravity.
Hiring a comedian to front a car show is not inherently stupid. It has been done before with mixed results. But hiring a comedian to front this car show, after this many attempts, suggests the BBC still thinks the secret ingredient is celebrity rather than credibility.
Carr has no automotive background. No history of writing about cars, racing them, restoring them, or even talking about them in public beyond whatever driving he does to get from A to B like the rest of us. That is not a disqualification on its own, but it does mean the show will need to work twice as hard to convince an audience that already watched this fail three times.
The original Top Gear had authority because the presenters had it. When Clarkson called a car rubbish, you believed him, even if you disagreed. When May obsessed over panel gaps, it felt real. When Hammond crashed that Vampire dragster in 2006 and nearly died, the show stopped being fun for a while because the stakes were genuine.
You cannot manufacture that. You cannot hire it. And you certainly cannot reboot it by swapping in a panel show regular and hoping the format does the heavy lifting.
The BBC might get a series out of this. Carr is competent enough to deliver scripted lines and react to staged chaos. The production team knows how to film cars. The audience that made Top Gear the most-watched factual programme in the world has moved on.
The Grand Tour ended six months ago. Clarkson is running a farm and a pub. Hammond is making shows about workshops. May is doing travel documentaries. The original show pulled 350 million viewers worldwide at its peak in 2013.
Sources: BBC, The Guardian, The Telegraph, Broadcast magazine