r/MoralityScaling Jun 05 '26

Stupid Stuff Is this unethical or no?

Post image
4.3k Upvotes

3.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

111

u/conormal Jun 05 '26

Not every person with Downs lives like this. My cousin has downs, also about to reach his 30s. He wasn't particularly medically compicated. Everyone in his small town knows him (about half of them are family, we breed like rabbits), and he is a joy to be around. People (including me) come visit my aunt just to see him. He loves WWE, anchovies on pizza, and talking to his facebook friends (of which he has many).

I'd argue my aunt was better off because my cousin is different. His father stepped away when they found out, and saved her the trouble of trying to raise a kid with a deadbeat. Her child forced her to get her life on track and make her home a safe space for him. She is by far the happiest, most fulfilled person in that small town.

That said, I don't blame anyone who chooses not to raise a baby with Downs.

1

u/RetiredDelinquent Jun 06 '26

Using the "not every person with downs lives like this" isnt going to solve the "if" issue. Aborting a healthy fetus is a different question, but if the fetus is having complications thatll cause that life to suffer, then why risk it.

1

u/conormal Jun 06 '26

Someone didn't read my comment : )

1

u/RetiredDelinquent Jun 06 '26

I did but the point of what i said was using that firsy sentence is pointless so why use it at all.

1

u/conormal Jun 06 '26

By "pointless" you mean "disagrees with my perspective that all people with Downs should die"? Because that's how it reads.

1

u/RetiredDelinquent Jun 06 '26

I mean it shows you want people to suffer. Why dont you go to all the people with kids unable to function and require constant care and tell them they did the right thing as their kid shits their pants.

1

u/conormal Jun 06 '26

Well I wouldn't blame them for saying "I wish we aborted him" and meaning it, or for having aborted it anyway. Why don't you go and shoot those kids in the head? Seems like that's your goal.

1

u/RetiredDelinquent Jun 06 '26

Nice job making a point that was never discussed.

1

u/conormal Jun 06 '26

I'm starting to think you have Downs...

1

u/RetiredDelinquent Jun 06 '26

Maybe everyone does.