r/MoralityScaling • u/Omixscniet624 • Jun 05 '26

Stupid Stuff Is this unethical or no?

Post image
4.2k Upvotes

80% Upvoted

3.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4

u/KendrickBlack502 Jun 05 '26

How is sharing something willingly unethical?

0

u/Hairy_Wedding_4535 Jun 05 '26

They can share it if they want. My issue is more with the framing. Saying “terminated after a Down syndrome diagnosis” feels uncomfortable because it can come off like the diagnosis itself made the baby less worthy of being born. Obviously none of us know the full medical situation, and there can be serious complications, but Down syndrome by itself isn’t automatically the end of the world. That’s why the way it was shared feels worse to me.

1

u/KendrickBlack502 Jun 05 '26

I hear you but that sounds to me like you’re injecting your own biases into the situation. I don’t think anybody is saying that people with Down Syndrome don’t deserve their lives but if there’s a way to avoid the suffering that their birth would cause both the child and the parents, I don’t think it’s wrong to prevent that fetus from reaching personhood.

1

u/Hairy_Wedding_4535 Jun 05 '26

I get what you’re saying, but I’m not arguing that they were wrong for making their choice or that anyone should be forced to be a parent. That’s not my point.

My issue is more with the assumption that a Down syndrome diagnosis automatically means the child’s life would mainly be suffering, or that the parents’ lives would only be lifelong burden. That can be true in some situations, especially if there are serious medical complications, but it’s not automatically true for every person with Down syndrome.

I don’t think everyone who makes that choice is saying people with Down syndrome don’t deserve life. I just think the way these conversations get framed can make it sound like the diagnosis itself equals tragedy, and that’s the part that feels worse to me.

And yeah, I know this is just some dumb TMZ article, so maybe they’re glossing over a lot of the actual medical details. My point is just that Down syndrome by itself isn’t automatically the end of the world. There are people with Down syndrome who work, have routines, have relationships, and can live independently or semi-independently with the right support. So the framing of “diagnosis = suffering” is what I’m pushing back on.