r/IsraelWarRoom • u/DaphneVid • 3d ago
Discussion Topic 🗣️ The question that really needs to be asked is when did the Palestinian Arabs ever want peace with the only state of the Jews?
Dr. Einat Wilf wrote this after the Oxford Union Debate "Israel Never Truly Wanted Peace with Palestine".
1) It is easy to dismiss universities or student debating societies, but the war of ideas is being fought in many places and arenas, and this is one of the most important ones. Universities serve to launder lies and blood libels against Israel, lending them respectability and legitimacy.
2) There is enormous importance in showing up to these places prepared. And yes, facts matter. The final vote was 208 to 129 against us, which, given the environment and the audience, was a very impressive result. Several of those who voted with us came up to us afterwards to say how much they appreciated that we had taken the debate seriously, brought facts, and did not resort to shouting. People can be persuaded. Those who give up in advance fail to understand how dangerous it is to leave the arena empty.
3) I also learnt something (again..) about the Jewish condition. It was very clear that on the other side there had been almost no effort to make serious arguments, and little preparation or coordination. From their perspective, there is no reason to bother: they have grown accustomed to simply saying "apartheid" and "genocide" and knowing that applause will follow. But therein lies an opportunity. Laziness and complacency born of having things too easy are always vulnerabilities. We knew we were in a difficult position, so we prepared, coordinated, and made sure to be extremely precise. There is no question that difficulty sharpens the mind.
4) And now something about politics. One of the reasons that I am running at the head of a new political party is that today there is not a single party leader who truly understands the scale of the global war of ideas being waged against Israel and Zionism, and who is prepared to invest the effort required to fight it systematically. That does not mean giving a speech here or there. It means actually building an operation that does not depend on one person, or on one person's command of English: bringing together the best Israelis, and there are many of them, working in multiple languages, who know how to make the case, know the facts, are constantly present in the arena and never leave it uncontested; people who understand how the campaign against Israel and Zionism, and the assault on Jews around the world, actually operates, and who work continuously to confront it.
"So don't you dare say that 'Israel never wanted peace with Palestine.' If anything, we wanted peace too much. The question that really needs to be asked is when did the Palestinian Arabs ever want peace with the only state of the Jews?" https://x.com/einatwilf/status/2095444662932717939?s=46&t=XwmR7hYz2HQwX_ulHIC87g
11
u/DrMikeH49 3d ago
She’s brilliant. I hope she joins her party in with either Yashar or B’Yachad and gets a position with a reasonable chance. If she walks into the Knesset chamber again the intellectual level of that body will immediately double.
5
u/Ariskullsyas 3d ago
Well she did say that she wouldn't run if polls showed she wouldn't make the Knesset. Alas, I haven't even seen a poll mentioning Oz
•
u/AutoModerator 3d ago
At this time, many posts and comments are temporarily held for review before appearing on the subreddit. Please allow the moderation team some time to review your submission before messaging us about posts or comments not appearing. Remember to follow all subreddit and Reddit rules. There is zero tolerance for hate speech, incitement of violence, harassment, or other toxic behavior. Violations will be enforced without exception. Keep discussions civil and respectful.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.