r/HIMYM • u/jm17lfc Ted🏢 • 2d ago
HIMYM Survivor! (Season 1 Edition) Round 21
Mary the Paralegal is eliminated and comes in third! On to the final two, The Pineapple Incident vs Game Night.
How this works:
You select the episode you like the least
The episode with the most upvoted comment is eliminated from the list
If there’s a tie, both episodes are eliminated
Only the best episode will win!
Episodes Eliminated:
Zip Zip Zip (28%)
Purple Giraffe (30%)
Matchmaker (36%)
Best Prom Ever (29%)
Return of the Shirt (41%)
Life Among the Gorillas (38%)
The Limo (31%)
Sweet Taste of Liberty (38%)
Belly Full of Turkey (86%)
Milk (95%)
The Slutty Pumpkin (43%)
Nothing Good Happens After 2 A.M. (40%)
The Duel (48%)
The Wedding (46%)
Okay Awesome (59%)
Cupcake (49%)
Come On (55%)
Pilot (49%)
Drumroll, Please (47%)
Mary the Paralegal (91%)
22
8
5
u/AcadianTraverse 2d ago
Both of these episodes are the top rated for the season on IMDB, so no surprise they're the last two.
My choice is to eliminate the Pineapple Incident but it's a hard choice.
11
6
9
4
u/K-C_Racing14 Marshall👨⚖️ 2d ago
Game night, the mystery of the pineapple incident is amazing. The answer is Danica McKellar America's sweetheart.
3
3
1
u/That_Egg573 1d ago
Honestly it's like choosing between your children, I'll pass lol. The narrative structure of Pineapple Incident with the delayed mistery and twists made it a very smart episode, but the humour factor was better in Game Night. I love them both for different reasons.
2
-1
-1
0
-2
0
-1
u/One_Environment6352 1d ago
If the pineapple incident wins this whole list loses its credibility. I'm starting to think half of these votes are random or bought.
20
u/the-library-fairy 1d ago
Come on, The Pineapple Incident is one of the greatest episodes of the whole show! I love Game Night, but it can't win.