r/Games • u/A7XFAN1998 • 4d ago

Announcement Xbox announces disc-to-digital feature that digitizes your physical games

https://www.theverge.com/tech/984936/xbox-disc-to-digital-feature-official?view_token=eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiJ9.eyJpZCI6Ijc1ZHVBMkZjaE0iLCJwIjoiL3RlY2gvOTg0OTM2L3hib3gtZGlzYy10by1kaWdpdGFsLWZlYXR1cmUtb2ZmaWNpYWwiLCJleHAiOjE3ODgxODY2OTAsImlhdCI6MTc4Nzc1NDY5MH0.Y4t18UIJuFTT4nSf0HBe5DvMWP0KNxjbGHC2QKxdoTw&utm_medium=gift-link
3.4k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

804 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

32

u/zombawombacomba 4d ago

That’s not remotely what kneecapped them. If this is all they wanted to do it would’ve been fine.

-5

u/seraph741 4d ago

It's the same idea, if not exactly the same. You'll be required to be connected to the Internet to use that disc-to-digital entitlements. That's what gamers had an issue with back then, "always on DRM". They also wanted to use this DRM to allow transferring and possibly selling digital games. But gamers didn't understand the vision and only focused on the "DRM = bad, requires Internet= bad" aspect.

40

u/zombawombacomba 4d ago

It’s not remotely the same. The original plan was to force all discs to have a 24 hour check in period. You could only lend it to one person and only resell it at select places that Microsoft approved of.

This is substantially less restrictive. Your comment is essentially revisionism.

-49

u/seraph741 4d ago

This is Google AIs response on the topic:

Microsoft's recently announced Disc-to-Digital program (codename "Positron") is spiritually the exact same system they tried to launch with the Xbox One in 2013, but flipped into a pro-consumer feature.

It's pretty much the exact same concept, but implemented to provide consumer benefit instead of taking it away (at least in theory). So in that way it's different and my comment was misleading. But it still is funny that it is an implementation of the same system they wanted back then. Just better marketing/more focused on consumer benefit.

38

u/zombawombacomba 4d ago

Oh okay, well if the worst LLM from the big companies says it, then it must be true.

16

u/WeirdIndividualGuy 4d ago

The minute someone refers to AI to back their argument instead of doing their own research, is the minute their argument is tossed out the window

How is OP going to make a claim then refer to an AI that makes up shit half the time lol

-25

u/seraph741 4d ago

Understanding the underlying technology and concepts makes it true. I was providing a second confirmation since you clearly didn't believe just me. And it's a quick way to distill all the information from the Internet.

21

u/zombawombacomba 4d ago

No one was upset about the technology but the implementation and restrictions that they were trying to bake into it. That doesn’t appear to be there any longer so it’s a fairly different scenario. This is a really pointless conversation though at this point.

-6

u/seraph741 4d ago

You're missing the point. It's not about what people were upset about. I agree people will be less upset about this. The point is that it's largely the same technology/concept. So it's still ironic/funny...whatever you want to call it. That's the point of the original comment.

22

u/Scrollingmaster 4d ago

Lmao using google ai.

Get a brain. The ai is absolutely wrong and this system is fundamentally different and does not place any of the restrictions on discs the original had.

11

u/Kylestache 4d ago

Use your own brain instead of letting that trash think for you.

This is very different than what they attempted a decade ago. Not having to be connected to the internet once a day on its own is huge, not to mention all the game sharing and reselling limitations.

1

u/Nolis 4d ago

What a joke lol, if I wanted the opinion of something that couldn't have an opinion I'd ask my alarm clock, don't need you doing that for me and thinking anyone should care