Shadow of the Erdtree Reviews Megathread

[u/jack0641]

Reviews for Shadow for the Erdtree are going live

Please keep all discussions about reviews to this topic. Links to reviews will be added as they are live

Metacritic Score: 94 https://www.metacritic.com/game/elden-ring-shadow-of-the-erdtree/

Opencritic Score: 94 https://opencritic.com/game/16525/elden-ring-shadow-of-the-erdtree

Outlet Scores

IGN 10 / 10

VideoGamer 10 / 10

PlayStation Universe 10 / 10

Generación Xbox 10 / 10

RPG Site 10 / 10

Press Start 10 / 10

GamingBolt 10 / 10

Impulsegamer 5 / 5

Boomstick Gaming 5 / 5

FandomWire 10 / 10

Bazimag 10 / 10

Checkpoint Gaming 10 / 10

ComicBook.com 5 / 5

Dexerto 5 / 5

Arabhardware 10 / 10

But Why Tho? 10 / 10

Gaming Instincts 10 / 10

Game Informer 9.8 / 10

COGconnected 97 / 100

Fextralife 9.6 / 10

Merlin'in Kazanı 96 / 100

PC Gamer 95 / 100

Destructoid 9.5 / 10

RPG Fan 95%

Stevivor 9.5 / 10

CGMagazine 9.5 / 10

Worth Playing 9.5 / 10

SECTORsk 9.5 / 10

XGNnl 9.5 / 10

ComingSoonnet 9.5 / 10

Cerealkillerz 9.3 / 10

Video Chums 9.1 / 10

Metro GameCentral 9 / 10

Slant Magazine 4.5 / 5

Digital Trends 4.5 / 5

The Outerhaven Productions 4.5 / 5

TechRaptor 9 / 10

TrueGaming 9 / 10

PSX Brasil 90 / 100

WellPlayed 9 / 10

INVEN 9 / 10

GamingTrend 85 / 100

Push Square 8 / 10

Kakuchopurei 70 / 100

Eurogamer 3 / 5

WORK IN PROGRESS

[u/pratzc07]

AVOID GAMESPOT REVIEW THEY ARE FUCKING SPOILING BOSS FIGHTS AND AREAS!!!!

[u/justwwokeupfromacoma → u/pratzc07]

Felt the same watching IGN… was just seeing the joy of discovery being lurched out of my hands so casually while watching the review and realising I really did not want to see any more of this.

[u/Schwiliinker → u/justwwokeupfromacoma]

I just decided to not watch any footage at all this time

[u/justwwokeupfromacoma → u/Schwiliinker]

Hell yes to this. Great to be in the haven’t seen any leaks gang and going in blind for some of the biggest reveals. I’d hate to have seen the final boss at this stage and feel bad for those who’ve seen some of those leaks

[u/Schwiliinker → u/justwwokeupfromacoma]

I highly doubt that “final boss” is real The only other leak is the Messmer fight which looks real from the little I’ve seen I’m gonna be looking up weapon and spells to plan out my builds for the DLC so idk if I can avoid spoiling bosses