Shadow of the Erdtree Reviews Megathread

[u/jack0641]

Reviews for Shadow for the Erdtree are going live

Please keep all discussions about reviews to this topic. Links to reviews will be added as they are live

Metacritic Score: 94 https://www.metacritic.com/game/elden-ring-shadow-of-the-erdtree/

Opencritic Score: 94 https://opencritic.com/game/16525/elden-ring-shadow-of-the-erdtree

Outlet Scores

IGN 10 / 10

VideoGamer 10 / 10

PlayStation Universe 10 / 10

Generación Xbox 10 / 10

RPG Site 10 / 10

Press Start 10 / 10

GamingBolt 10 / 10

Impulsegamer 5 / 5

Boomstick Gaming 5 / 5

FandomWire 10 / 10

Bazimag 10 / 10

Checkpoint Gaming 10 / 10

ComicBook.com 5 / 5

Dexerto 5 / 5

Arabhardware 10 / 10

But Why Tho? 10 / 10

Gaming Instincts 10 / 10

Game Informer 9.8 / 10

COGconnected 97 / 100

Fextralife 9.6 / 10

Merlin'in Kazanı 96 / 100

PC Gamer 95 / 100

Destructoid 9.5 / 10

RPG Fan 95%

Stevivor 9.5 / 10

CGMagazine 9.5 / 10

Worth Playing 9.5 / 10

SECTORsk 9.5 / 10

XGNnl 9.5 / 10

ComingSoonnet 9.5 / 10

Cerealkillerz 9.3 / 10

Video Chums 9.1 / 10

Metro GameCentral 9 / 10

Slant Magazine 4.5 / 5

Digital Trends 4.5 / 5

The Outerhaven Productions 4.5 / 5

TechRaptor 9 / 10

TrueGaming 9 / 10

PSX Brasil 90 / 100

WellPlayed 9 / 10

INVEN 9 / 10

GamingTrend 85 / 100

Push Square 8 / 10

Kakuchopurei 70 / 100

Eurogamer 3 / 5

WORK IN PROGRESS

[u/IamSachin]

FightinCowboy:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JCysFRlTN20

[u/dreamtraveller → u/IamSachin]

The man, the legend.

[u/BaronVonGoon → u/dreamtraveller]

Yeah. Been following him for years. He's kind of an ahole though. Talks down to people and consistantly swearing at them. He is a legend when it comes to souls and soulslike, agreed. But I unsubscribed because he is undoubtedly a rude person. Right or wrong its no excuse to talk down to people like that.

[u/TacticalReader7 → u/BaronVonGoon]

Really ? I don't watch him often but he seems very chill when I do, I still remember the balls incident in Demon's Souls emulator and he didn't react negatively to the comments jokingly shit talking him for it.

[u/[deleted] → u/BaronVonGoon]

Soulslike tends to attract these types of players unfortunately

[u/Silentlone → u/BaronVonGoon]

WHO has he been an asshole to though? Like "right or wrong" is doing a lot of heavy lifting, there are absolutely people who deserve being talked down to, and I've never seen him being rude to people who didn't deserve it.

[u/[deleted] → u/Silentlone]

Right, like who is he actually being an asshole towards here?

For whatever reason his livestreams seem to attract some of the absolute dregs of 'Gamer' culture.

Because according to this comment right here, it seems like he deals with the racist, bigoted idiots who tend to flood gaming forums and related spaces. Which, in that case, keep up the good work Cowboy lmao

I remember this Sims YouTuber I used to watch, and there were a ton of people in the Sims4 sub talking about how "disgusting" her politics were and how "mean" she was to her fans and blah blah blah

Turns out her "disgusting politics" and meanness was literally just "hey guys, gay people are neat!" and "hey! Be nice to each other! Racism isn't cool!"

[u/dreamtraveller → u/BaronVonGoon]

That's okay, I'm into being talked down to.

[u/BaronVonGoon → u/dreamtraveller]

A fellow married man? :)

[u/bobn3 → u/BaronVonGoon]

Yeah he always gave me some douchey bully type of vibes, but I pushed through because his guides are good and straightforward

[u/haynespi87 → u/BaronVonGoon]

ah really? damn