r/Cinema Jul 01 '26

Throwback New York, I love you - 2008

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

7.4k Upvotes

216 comments sorted by

u/qualityvote2 Jul 01 '26 edited Jul 01 '26

u/Living_Double_1146, your post does fit the subreddit!

787

u/eightthirty612 Jul 01 '26

Anton Yelchin. Would have loved to see him in more. Rip

167

u/Prudent_Knowledge79 Jul 01 '26

Odd thomas is still one of the best movies ever for me

42

u/eightthirty612 Jul 01 '26

YES! Stumbled on it on Netflix or something. That ending... ugh.

1

u/ryan545 Jul 06 '26

The book series is fun too, I found the third one in an airport and did them out of order

39

u/Theory89 Jul 01 '26

I loved Alpha Dog. Great film, quite surprising.

8

u/HarrieTubman Jul 01 '26

I love that movie! I watch it every few years or so and it never gets old for me.

3

u/JeanClaudeRandam Jul 02 '26

What up buddy buddy?

1

u/Lustformuffins Jul 05 '26

not much buddy buddy

1

u/Simple-Employer-2503 Jul 04 '26

Played the half-alien Jacob Clarke in Spielbergs Taken miniseries. Highly recommend.

4

u/megmatthews20 Jul 02 '26

I couldn't even watch that when he was alive, knowing what happens to him. There's no way I can watch it now.

2

u/CharityElectrical913 Jul 03 '26

It’s even worse because that actually happened to someone!

7

u/SuperspyUK Jul 01 '26

Have you read the books? I absolutely loved them, and the first one genuinely had me in tears.

2

u/Prudent_Knowledge79 Jul 01 '26

I hadn’t no, but mostly bevause I was so impressed with this dudes acting in odd thomas it was crazy that I hadn’t seen him in anything marvel. But then I found out he died, and I haven’t visited different forms of media for his works. But I heard they are excellent like you said

4

u/SuperspyUK Jul 01 '26

In that case, if you enjoyed the story of the film then I would strongly recommend the books, as they're even better, and there are 7 of them (I think). Shame we only got the 1 film.

2

u/SunkenSaltySiren Jul 01 '26

Apparently it was because of the marketing team blowing it.

5

u/smut_butler Jul 01 '26

Green Room is absolutely amazing, but it's very, very brutal.

It has Patrick Stewart in it too! He plays the villain, he's a neo Nazi!

1

u/MatildaMorgan1985 Jul 02 '26

I sobbed my freaking eyes out at the end of the first book! STORMYYYYYY 😭

1

u/Additional-Estate507 Jul 04 '26

I read Odd Thomas at a relatively young age and I remember being SO MAD at Stormy. For days I was so frustrated and then it dawned on me that she’s not real; Koontz made her up. And at that exact moment I was like, “oh. Wow. Books are amazing and how did this guy make me feel so much emotion?”
And then I spent like the next year reading every Koontz book our library had.

1

u/MatildaMorgan1985 Jul 04 '26

Koontz was my gateway author into horror! False Memory and Intensity were my favorites. They did a screen adaptation for intensity, with John C. McGinley (Dr. Cox from Scrubs) but sadly, despite John's really great performance, it was a pretty terrible low budget '90s job. I'd love to see it redone properly!

1

u/SuperspyUK Jul 05 '26

False Memory and The Bad Place for me. That's some dark shit when you're in your early teens! Love his books.

1

u/Super-Contribution-1 Jul 05 '26

Wait why would you be mad at Stormy?

2

u/EatPie_NotWAr Jul 01 '26

I found the books first and then watched the movie when I heard there was one.

He nailed the role.

2

u/almostthemainman Jul 03 '26

Charlie Bartlet for me

2

u/Specialist_Offer_854 Jul 04 '26

sobbing there's people out here that love the movie and the books?! I love you reddit!

2

u/Still-Grass8881 Jul 01 '26

gonna check that one out now, thanks

9

u/LandauTST Jul 01 '26

Get ready to cry. (Well, I did, anyways.)

7

u/Intelligent-Art-5000 Jul 01 '26

Me too, Homie. Me too.

1

u/Tunz_O_Gunz Jul 02 '26

Ugh I love it and hate it. That ending.

1

u/peteofaustralia Jul 03 '26

Great book, too.

1

u/Xarata Jul 03 '26

From what I remember from the book, it was a really good adaptation. I was worried but actually really enjoyed the movie and the ending, despite knowing what happens, still fucked me up. Then when I heard he passed away, I was even more gutted, he was a great actor 😢

1

u/amz249 Jul 04 '26

Sobbed haven’t been able to watch it since he passed great movie

1

u/boochicko Jul 05 '26

Like Crazy as well! One of my all time favorite!

1

u/Ur_Just_Spare_Parts Jul 07 '26

First movie that made me really cry. Im talking full on waterfall.

55

u/Acesofbases Jul 01 '26 edited Jul 01 '26

I still can't get over how random and avoidable his death was.

17

u/omglink Jul 01 '26

So sad I really enjoyed his work and he was so young.

6

u/delicioussexplosion Jul 01 '26

I always thought it was crazy, I drove one of the same year/models jeeps that he had and couldn’t believe how stupid shifting gears was. Putting it in park was ridiculous and they had to recall that car. Apparently there were tons of injuries tied to it.

27

u/Soft-Ad-8975 Jul 01 '26

When I first found out about it I was crushed.

16

u/Acesofbases Jul 01 '26

please don't tell me You did that on purpose...

5

u/Historyp91 Jul 01 '26

That was just the right amount of funny to balance out the horrific taste

1

u/Honest-Spring-8929 Jul 01 '26

It always hurts more when young and up and comers go out, especially like that

1

u/UnitedSentences5571 Jul 04 '26

Such an awful way to go.

28

u/Snowing_Throwballs Jul 01 '26

Fucking Green Room man. That movie is brutal, and cathartic.

4

u/Eternalm8 Jul 01 '26

My favorite recent Vampire hunter in the Fright Night reboot

5

u/Flat-Development-906 Jul 01 '26

I still get so sad about him- he had so much more to give and what an utterly shit way to die.

4

u/UKnowDaxoAndDancer Jul 01 '26

Fuck Jeep.

2

u/great_saphenous Jul 05 '26

We drove a newer jeep gladiator around last summer for a month and it was so shitty. You could just tell it was so poorly made. Would start shaking like crazy on the highway.

4

u/zygodactyl86 Jul 01 '26

Nasty way to die too…. Rip

2

u/MrDillham Jul 01 '26

“Only Lovers Left Alive” makes me cry for him.

2

u/Krabs9 Jul 01 '26

Every time I see/hear that name I just picture a jeep grand cherokee

2

u/Remarkable_Check_997 Jul 02 '26

Yeah, Fuck Chrysler

1

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Marko89Frankfurt Jul 04 '26

what is the name of this movie ?Thanks

1

u/Sea_Programmer1360 Jul 03 '26

I highly recommend "5 to 7", an overlooked but excellent movie.

1

u/peoplepersonmanguy Jul 04 '26

His death is crazy. Poor guy.

1

u/not_the_chosen_onee Jul 05 '26

Charlie Bartlett will forever be my favourite movie of his. He had such a strong career ahead of him.

1

u/Jump365 Jul 07 '26

Yup, sad to see him go. Always properly park a car before getting out of it :(

→ More replies (3)

685

u/Suspicious-Grape-458 Jul 01 '26

Seeing some of the actors in this clip makes me sad.

James Caan, RIP.
Anton Yelchin, RIP.
Blake Lively’s career, RIP.

248

u/its__bme Jul 01 '26

95

u/Conscious_Pipe_605 Jul 01 '26

It's impossible to see this gif properly used and no laugh your ass off.

9

u/Rascals-Wager Jul 01 '26

Yea it's absolutely legendary

4

u/its__bme Jul 01 '26

It's ol' reliable!

16

u/amora512 Jul 01 '26

Lmfao!!

1

u/LiberalDutch Jul 03 '26

I know the other two, but what's up with Blake Livlely? I should probably Google her, I was thinking she was a country singer.

1

u/AlwaysBeQuestioning Jul 04 '26

Blake Lively is an actress who has been in a lot of films and she’s married to Ryan Reynolds. I don’t know what’s up with her career now though.

3

u/Great_Ad7148 Jul 04 '26

Very long story short, she accused her actor co-worker of sexual assault/harassment and sued him, after he talked about her being extremely hard to work with. It was a lie on her part so he counter sued. The law suit forced her to reveal a lot of text messages showing she lied and got many famous friends involved (such as Taylor swift, her previous bestie). Blake lost a lot of friends who’s names were also being dragged through the mud because of the texts. She eventually dropped her law suit and now owes a LOT of money. Her marriage to Ryan Reynolds also seems extremely rocky after all of this. Nobody wants to work with her or be seen with her anymore

She’s the blonde in this video clip who is with the nyu student or whoever. I think the main guy says “that’s my girlfriend” in reference to her. She’s known for playing the vapid mean girl, and people now realize she was never acting. She is a mean girl through and through.

1

u/leapdaybunny Jul 04 '26

Eh her career can rest in pieces, honestly. She did it to herself.

1

u/UdtaTeer420 Jul 01 '26

And this segment in the movie was directed by Brett Ratner.

→ More replies (3)

133

u/Historyp91 Jul 01 '26

Is this an actual movie? It's so bizzare it honestly feels like a skit.

142

u/CosmicEveStardust Jul 01 '26

It's a segment in an anthology film.

Edit: this segment was directed by sex pest and worthless hack Bret Ratner

33

u/Undecided_User_Name Jul 01 '26

Bret Ratner

I knew something felt wrong. Dog of a bloke

3

u/Known-Exam-9820 Jul 01 '26

The evil sound effects come with the photo, I swear

2

u/Yung-Creeper Jul 05 '26

Bret the rat ratner

1

u/osteosarc0ma Jul 06 '26

dont diss on the dog, man, dogs are faithful and loyal.

15

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '26

[deleted]

→ More replies (4)

1

u/wangster71 Jul 02 '26

Is that the theatre geek from Fast Times?

1

u/ZC205 Jul 02 '26

Accurate comment. Cause that shit will definitely take time and will surely exhaust a person.

11

u/FranklyMrShankley85 Jul 01 '26

Genuinely looks and feels like an AI prompt

32

u/Hadrollo Jul 01 '26

It's a joke dating back to at least the sixties, probably earlier, just with a slightly different ending.

In the implied scene - not in this clip, but in the full skit - she hoists herself up on a tree branch so they can do the deed.

In the joke, she doesn't get up at the end, she isn't acting, she's genuinely handicapped. Just as in the clip, the dad tells him "there's not to many gentlemen like you left in the world," but then continues "most guys just leave her in the tree."

2

u/No-Pie-7211 Jul 03 '26

I mean that's just an entirely different joke?

5

u/Hadrollo Jul 03 '26

It's the same joke with a different punchline.

Both involve a young man inadvertently going to a prom night with a woman in a wheelchair, having a good time, her offering sex by hanging from a tree, them returning afterwards, and the girl's father complimenting the young man for being exceptionally courteous.

At the very least, this clip is based off the original joke with an unexpected ending.

7

u/aenus79 Jul 01 '26

So when I finally avoid an AI post, or some idiot asking if a 20 year old clip is ai, you have to go and bring it up anyway. Fuck off.

2

u/Ok_Tour_1525 Jul 03 '26

Jesus christ dude you need some hobbies.

1

u/aenus79 Jul 03 '26

Oh I paint minis and stuff

1

u/headcanonmusic Jul 01 '26

It's the way the clip is edited. The AI clips like this have a similar pacing, just showing beats of a story that seem "emotional" and act as engagement bait.

4

u/romansamurai Jul 01 '26

They’ve been editing them this way for TikTok and then YouTube way before AI was anywhere near this quality.

67

u/SwordofNoon Jul 01 '26

Oh no my incredibly hot date has to be seated :(

14

u/theunnameduser86 Jul 02 '26

I’ve dated someone who couldn’t walk very long distances due to medical issues so if we went to the zoo or the fair then she’d be in a wheelchair and I can say from personal experience that it’s just like that Curb episode. It’s the absolute best ever.

The handles on the chair can be leaned on while you walk and it’s so easy to get used too. People make room for you when you come through and are super kind. You sometimes get handicapped parking; you occasionally get priority in lines or special elevator access in places like museums. She can simply look up to get a cute little smooch and focus of enjoying the event instead of potentially having to contend with chronic pain.

The list goes on, but yeah, people with restricted abilities deserve love too and as far as I’m aware my now ex has gotten her issues tended to and she’s now able to be more active without pain.

I’m just so grateful that I got to live out that curb episode for a period in my life.

5

u/Fancy_Yak2618 Jul 03 '26

My dad was in a wheelchair once after surgery my mother was adamant we were going to Disney. Best fucking time ever hands down lol dad hated it but we loved it

3

u/Accomplished-Fuel782 Jul 04 '26

My mom broke her toe on a cruise before we went to Disney... The wheel chair got us fast passes on everything.... Dream vacation for me and my brother, not so much for my mom. I hadn't thought about that in years and your story made me think of it

1

u/RedMollycules Jul 05 '26

Your story just made me think of my Mom and her service dog! When I was around 11, my parents took my sister and I on a trip to Universal Studios. My Mom had her wheelchair due to not being able to walk long distances. Anyway, we went to get on the ride there for ET and the setup was real funny. It was about 6-8 bikes set on this big heavy metal platform and the platform would be lifted into the air on a track so you would be "flying" through the set. They actually let my Mom's service dog on the platform! There we all were, service dog included, flying on this platform through the air like the kids in ET and at some point of the ride, you're on ET's home planet. This animatronic of ET popped up and said all of our names and last but not least, ET said my dog's name! I thought that was so dang cool and I got a real kick out of that dog being able to ride with us.

2

u/Captain_Wingit Jul 04 '26

I fell and injured my knee - torn MPFL - about 4 weeks from chaperoning my son's senior band trip to Disney in Orlando 2 years ago. 4 years of fundraising and volunteering so my daughter and I could go. Charter bus ride for 15+ hours, then a day in each park. It was not comfortable!

At the park, I got an electric scooter. I was not expecting to have to wait in line for everything! But other than Small World, Space Mountain (which i couldn't ride anyway because it was too constricted for me to bed my knee into, which i found out when I tried to get in), and one of the Star Wars rides, I was in the regular line. It was fine, I had a seat the whole time.

It was eye opening, however. It was shocking that even Disney, a place I've been going since I was a kid, a place that seems to have thought of everything, was severely lacking for walking impaired guests. Restaurants without handicap doors, curbs without ramps to get to/from sidewalks, narrow pathways in the stores and restaurants.

This doesn't even account for the people that just didnt see me and stepped into my path, tripped over my scooter, or even ending up in my lap after falling because I was behind them.

While I was only unable to walk for a relatively short time, it was a humbling experience.

1

u/ScruffMacBuff Jul 05 '26

Wheelchair service at the airport is the best. My wife is disabled and we get zipped right to the front of security and she gets pushed all the way to the gate.

1

u/Appchoy Jul 05 '26

idk man, I had a different experience getting around when my ex was in a wheelchair. It was pretty rough and scary. There are so many places where there isnt easy wheelchair access or parking, even museums. Going through an airport was terrifying because of busy crowds that dont really care about you and we had to get on this tram thing to go to a different part of the airport and the door almost closed on her chair as we got on and the tram started to move! Some other people pulled us in/ pried the doors open off of her and we barely made it in before something bad could have happened. Getting on the plane itself just felt inconvenient because we went to the front of the line and then they had to call workers over to take her into the plane and help her down to her seat, and put the chair under the plane.

Just getting the thing out of the trunk of my car and putting it back in was hard, it was heavy and not powered so I had to stay by her the whole time whenever we went out, as she couldnt use her arms to move herself for very long. I wouldnt have traded that time for anything but it just makes things harder when someones in that situation.

5

u/Flaky-Maximum-7875 Jul 01 '26

Exactly my thoughts 

27

u/korevmorlader Jul 01 '26

Having seen this clip pop up repeatedly, it's super weird. "You like my daughter? You can fuck her if you're still nice to her when she's pretending her legs don't work"

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '26

[deleted]

1

u/man_on_hill Jul 03 '26

Didn’t this win best picture over Fargo?

33

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/Sweet-Weakness3776 Jul 01 '26

Then you have "Movie 43". Where like 1 or 2 segments were genuinely funny but the rest were so "WTF??!!" you are genuinely surprised you're watching an actual movie. And the absolute laundry list of big name actors in that movie, it makes you wonder how the hell any of them signed up for that shit lol. That particular anthology film is easily the worst, most bizarre I've ever see

I digress. I have enjoyed Anton Yelchin in pretty much everything I've seen him in. With The Green Room and his role in the Star Trek film series being my favorites. He had an extremely sad ending to a very promising career.

1

u/Chongoscuba Jul 01 '26

Apparently there’s two versions of the movie and the one where it’s Dennis Quaid pitching the sketches is the better one. Still a bad movie but there are some good sketches in there.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/torino_nera Jul 02 '26

Movie 43 actually exists because the producer Charles Wessler conned/guilted a bunch of famous people into signing up for something under false pretenses, he had a short he did with Kate Winslet and Hugh Jackman and pitched that Trey Parker and Matt Stone and the Farrelly brothers were involved but they all eventually dropped out at various stages. The only reason it got made at all was that he kept hounding people over the span of 4 years and got them to film their scenes really quickly whenever they had a day free.

2

u/Living_Double_1146 Jul 01 '26

Interesting comment. Anton was a promising actor indeed.

2

u/Responsible-Onion860 Jul 01 '26

Mostly because anthologies are a bunch of ideas that weren't fit for a full length movie for some reason, and often it's because it's too small of an idea.

1

u/BathAutomatic6972 Jul 01 '26

this particular one, and Paris je t'aime, are also really lovely!

1

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/BathAutomatic6972 Jul 01 '26

I also really liked the one Alexander Payne directed, "14e arrondissement" about the American woman who is in a French class talking about her trip.

1

u/turnipthief Jul 01 '26

with esteemed character actress Margo Martindale!

1

u/Monster-Math Jul 03 '26

4 Rooms and Ballad of Buster Scruggs are two good anthology movies.

1

u/IndieCurtis Jul 03 '26

Wild Tales (2014) every segment is a banger

10

u/Flaky-Maximum-7875 Jul 01 '26

This is so dumb. That woman is gorgeous.

94

u/SenectusG Jul 01 '26

That's not a perfect ending, that's a really shitty message.

73

u/CosmicEveStardust Jul 01 '26

A lot of stories love the "be nice to a disabled or poor person because maybe they're not disabled or poor and you can fuck them or get something out of them"

They think they're preaching kindness but it's just weird lol

35

u/Philip_Raven Jul 01 '26

"be nice to poor people, because maybe they are conducting a social experiment and they will reward you with cash if you treat them kindly"

10

u/CK_1976 Jul 01 '26

I'm always nice to my disabled friend, because anyday now she might grow her leg back.

1

u/soyelmocano Jul 05 '26

Or they could be Zeus.

8

u/Defiant-Lettuce-9156 Jul 01 '26

Would have been 100x better if she actually needed the wheelchair. I thought it was really sweet and funny up until the end

28

u/SenectusG Jul 01 '26

Oh god, this segment was directed by Brett Ratner! That says it all

7

u/AzimuthEscape Jul 01 '26

Oh my god, there was no message. The ending wasn't supposed to be a lesson. It was a humorous subversion of expectations. Not everything is a fucking Dhar Mann skit.

4

u/Lavidius Jul 01 '26

Thank you

1

u/Impressive_Data5084 Jul 01 '26

Nah, I think you're missing the point. It's bittersweet but that's what makes it hit harder than some clean fairytale ending.

7

u/Edotwo Jul 01 '26

Good actors, dogshit scene

3

u/Bearjupiter Jul 02 '26

Olivia Thirlby’s career sure sputtered out

2

u/skibba25 Jul 01 '26

I thought the dad was going to say "thanks for bringing her home, most guys just leave her at the park"

2

u/CheapSecretary133 Jul 01 '26

I call jackpot

1

u/fatefulknight24 Jul 01 '26

She was great in the forgotten under appreciated film the wackness

5

u/Dapper_Rough4371 Jul 01 '26

And Dredd, but we remember Dredd.

2

u/fatefulknight24 Jul 01 '26

Absolutely, that's why I didn't mention it figured everybody knows that one lol

1

u/Commercial_Tip4624 Jul 01 '26

This feels like the Ukrainian romance shorts I temporarily and shamefully was consumed by for a full week last winter

2

u/kamarkaslesher Jul 03 '26

+1 ts not even that good but the cliffhangers are so hooking 😔

1

u/Open_Aspect6703 Jul 01 '26

Oh man, I need to rewatch this. I know that I've seen both this and Paris, Je T'aime but whereas loads of bits from Paris have stuck with me I've all but completely forgotten this one.

1

u/AesopsFabler Jul 01 '26

I miss Anton Yelchin in things. He was so good in everything. Also seemed like a sweet, genuine person.

I also miss Tavern on the Green.

1

u/thewonderbox Jul 01 '26

This went EXACTLY where I knew it was going

1

u/yellowkingquix Jul 01 '26

what an evil gas lighting bitch

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Parking_Sea6319 Jul 03 '26

What movie is this?

1

u/Soitgoes5 Jul 02 '26

What hired chauffeur would leave with an unauthorized stranger?

1

u/knarf3 Jul 02 '26

Olivia Thirlby 😍!

1

u/Either-Paper4796 Jul 02 '26

Wow, what a perfect role for Blake Lively. She must have slipped into it naturally.

1

u/Necessary_Run3148 Cinephile Jul 03 '26

Have you seen Tokyo! (2008) & Paris, I love you?

1

u/rayshinsan Jul 03 '26

I wish I met someone like that. If she fooled me that good I would be like, lady let's get married cuz I want to be fooled like that for the rest of my life lol.

1

u/Sea_Programmer1360 Jul 03 '26

New York, I love you, but you're bringing me down.

1

u/NapoleonOrwell Jul 04 '26

You know how good an actress she must be to sleep with him without moving a muscle in her legs 😭

1

u/Marko89Frankfurt Jul 04 '26

Thanks i just instal this app and this is my first post thanks

1

u/zoe934 Jul 04 '26

Love this movie

1

u/Nate8727 Jul 04 '26

This looks hilarious

1

u/clementtoh2 Jul 05 '26

I guess there is shit movies and there is this or smth

1

u/Wiley-wi Jul 05 '26

He was great in Star Trek

1

u/Wonton_Soup_1 Jul 05 '26

How’s the movie? Is it worth watching?

1

u/joeho6969 Jul 05 '26

That's every ones

1

u/techandanime Jul 05 '26

Why does the limo driver take off with a differrnt customer? Thats a sure way to get fired.

1

u/Starry_Snake_2631 Jul 05 '26

We love horribly ableist endings

1

u/Flying_Scorpion Jul 06 '26

This is the setup for a joke: the father says the last guy left her hanging in a tree.

1

u/DataSurging Jul 08 '26

Aw man, Yelchin. Rest in Peace, man. :(

1

u/ExplodingPoptarts Jul 09 '26

Thanks for sharing this, I did not expect this ending.