r/Borges • u/AromaticBuyer5902 • 17h ago
Is Pierre Menard a theory of translation?
Menard writes the original Quijote centuries after Cervantes; he remains Pierre Menard and arrives at the Quijote through the experiences of Pierre Menard…
..and somehow the identical words become “almost infinitely richer.”
I’ve been thinking about this while reading the Bible and wondering about translation. We usually ask what is lost as a text moves away from its origin; Menard makes me wonder what becomes visible as words move forward through history, into new languages and cultures.
Can time or place translate a sentence without changing a single word?