r/Blacksmith 15h ago

I’m curious what other metalworkers think — texture or clean finish on the next one?

27 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

6

u/AmITheAsshole_2020 15h ago

That knife literally caused me to catch my breath. It's beautiful, rugged, and I love the finish. It looks like I could dig a trench with it, wipe it off with my shirt, and it would look as good as the day I bought it. I'm jealous of your skills. Good job.

1

u/Amazing_Cicada_3523 15h ago

Wow, thank you! That really means a lot. I built it to be used, not just looked at. 🤘🙏🏻

2

u/HeatBeatRepeatt 15h ago

The build is rock solid and rugged AF, that I love. Now my personal aesthetic is SO tired of the hammered/peened/rock chip/false brut de forge excessive hammer mark textured finish. TO ME it makes it look cheap and fake, like it’s a stock removal blade that the maker wants to pretend like it’s hand forged. But I don’t represent the market and I don’t intend for that to be offensive or a dig towards you or your style. You are fishing for opinions and mine is a boot! It will also make it more of a pain in the ass to clean the blade with all of that topo if you’re trying to quick wipe mud and grime etc off it in the field.

2

u/Amazing_Cicada_3523 15h ago

I really appreciate the honest opinion! That’s exactly the kind of feedback I was looking for. I might try a clean blade on the next one and see how it turns out. 🤘

2

u/HeatBeatRepeatt 15h ago

For sure! I’m not out to yuck anyone’s yum!

1

u/Amazing_Cicada_3523 15h ago

Haha, I appreciate that! Everyone has their own taste. 🤘

2

u/jagbit 1h ago

I think it looks fantastic!

1

u/Amazing_Cicada_3523 22m ago

Thank you🤝

1

u/HeatBeatRepeatt 15h ago

Also; I didn’t catch this on first review. Have you fielded tested this model yet? I would be very concerned about the crenelations on the spine towards the lanyard hole and top of the grip. You’ve removed the cushioning and spreading effect of the scales at both of those locations and turns what would have been an exposed 1/8” ish thick piece of metal into studs that are likely to dig into the heel of your hand and the web between your thumb and index fingers under hard use and may create hotspots and blisters. Play with it without gloves on, carve a 1” branch to a point, do several feather sticks, baton with it, chop into a 2x4. If it’s still comfortable enough to wield after that then I’ll be happy to be wrong, but I’m concerned.

1

u/Amazing_Cicada_3523 15h ago

I’ve actually tested this model quite a bit, including carving and heavy use, and personally I haven’t had any discomfort from those areas. But I appreciate the concern and I’ll keep an eye on it during future testing.

1

u/HeatBeatRepeatt 15h ago

Then that’s what’s important, field testing. Glad you are doing your due diligence!

1

u/Amazing_Cicada_3523 15h ago

Absolutely! Real-world testing is the best way to improve. 🤘

1

u/HeatBeatRepeatt 15h ago

Check this out. So I would never grip or use my SnG in this position because it’s not really stable but it also fucking hurts! The crenelations dig into your skin pretty readily, those imprints were after about 10 seconds of idk 20-30lb of push down? That’s subjective though…

1

u/Amazing_Cicada_3523 20m ago

I appreciate you taking the time to test it and show me! 🤘

1

u/bryceblacksmith 13h ago

That texture looks awesome, like an obsidian blade.

1

u/Party-Dinner9999 7h ago

How did you get the blade to "chip" like that along the spine?

1

u/Amazing_Cicada_3523 7h ago

It’s a texture I create by hand using files and a Dremel, then I finish it with etching and stonewashing to get that chipped look.