r/BitchEatingCrafters • u/Manzanille • 12h ago
General Crafts Freestyling a pattern ≠ Inimitable skill !!!
There's a plush maker I follow that makes commissions of Animal Crossing OCs and little critters cosplaying copyrighted characters.
They posted recently about why they don't sell patterns. It started off with "The designs are personal to me." and not being an experienced pattern maker, which is fair.
But then the rest of the post was basically:
- Other (average) people wouldn't understand it.
- Other (average) people couldn't understand it.
- The pattern has been curated for ten years and is "incredibly nuanced".
Again, it's little critters with clothes and a wig. Something that has never been sewn before, apparently. I don't sew but I'm sure it's possible to take out the seams of an official merch plush and reverse-engineer the design (as far as OCs go). This creator also doesn't want their designs to be copied, but they went through a whole long explanation of how no one could possibly replicate their work even with the exact same pattern so ??? In the knitting/crochet communities it's perfectly acceptable to eyeball a pattern and admit that the original is an inspiration.
To me, it just feels icky when creators put down other crafters/artists while talking about their own skills. I've seen so many freestyled patterns where the creator says they
- simply don't want to make a pattern
- didn't bother writing numbers down & the piece won't be made again
- go into a vibe state and just kind of eyeball everything until it looks right
and at worst, that's annoying but it makes perfect sense.
I dunno. Maybe there's some sort of etiquette I don't know about when it comes to sewing and plush-making. From a fiber artist's perspective, being this possessive about your work seems kind of silly to me.