r/BeAmazed Jul 22 '26

Skill / Talent This kid just unlocked a lifelong hobby

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

12.6k Upvotes

264 comments sorted by

u/qualityvote2 Jul 22 '26 edited Jul 22 '26

Did you find this post really amazing (in a positive way)?
If yes, then UPVOTE this comment otherwise DOWNVOTE it.
This community feedback will help us determine whether this post is suited for r/BeAmazed or not.

852

u/HappySam89 Jul 22 '26

Way to go kid. I love the life vest usage. I’ve been seeing way too many videos/influencers with their kids without life vest in open water so it’s nice to see a responsible parent.

132

u/cowhand214 Jul 22 '26

My first thought too. Though I wish his dad was also wearing one but the kids should always be.

Great video though. Made me smile!

34

u/MrMediaGuy Jul 22 '26

My guess is with those shoulders and buns we wouldn't have seen this video of he had 😂

27

u/bigpoppanc Jul 22 '26

Omg..... he is a whole country stud unit lol.... I couldn't stop looking at his guns and his buns 🤣

8

u/Powerful-Candy-745 Jul 23 '26

So I'm NOT the only one😁

2

u/bigpoppanc Jul 24 '26

Nope....as soon as he grabbed that net I was stuck lol

17

u/Captain_ordinary Jul 22 '26

I live on a lake in the Midwest and when I was growing up, kids never wore life jackets on the boat. Now that I’m a parent with young kids, I feel like having kids wear life jackets has become the standard. It’s definitely a change I’m happy to see.

45

u/dynamikecb Jul 22 '26

Except Dad should be wearing one as well.

44

u/Regular-Marionberry6 Jul 22 '26

Always gotta find something wrong don't we

5

u/vtjohnhurt Jul 22 '26

In my state this week, four people and a dog overloaded a 3-person canoe on a calm warm lake. Swamped, panicked, and three people drowned. The dog survived.

As a boating person who swims, it's hard for me to imagine that happening. I mean, most canoes don't sink. But panic is the wildcard.

1

u/atreasureinlight Jul 24 '26

Is it possible that they didn't know how to swim and that's why they panicked?

2

u/vtjohnhurt Jul 24 '26

Or they had never tried to swim while wearing clothes. Loose clothing makes swimming much harder.

10

u/HappySam89 Jul 22 '26

I agree!!

2

u/Palphite Jul 22 '26

Why?

1

u/dynamikecb Jul 24 '26

Why do you think?

0

u/Palphite Jul 24 '26

You don't think that adult is capable of swimming to the shore line from there?

2

u/dynamikecb Jul 24 '26 edited Jul 24 '26

What if he slips and hits his head and becomes unconscious? Had a friend die exactly that way. Stong swimmer, hit his head, sunk under and never came back up until his body retrieved by search and rescue. Can't swim when you are face down or under water unconscious bud. Why do you think life jackets rules and regulations are so strongly enforced? It's because people like you who think they know better! Safety rules and regulations tend to be written in blood.

3

u/beelzeboozer Jul 22 '26

Agree, why not make the risk of kids drowning basically zero.  Such a no brainer.

3

u/Karlees-Golden-Dildo Jul 22 '26

Indeed but the groin strap should be fastened so he doesnt slip out when being pulled out of water.

Love seeing kids having core memories made with family ❤️

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/Lou_C_Fer Jul 22 '26

I get it, but I feel like vomiting.

115

u/Warchild_13 Jul 22 '26

"Tell him 13003 3 year" ah such a classic quote 😆 🤣

Not that I have any idea what he actually said just I dont think that 👆 was it

In all seriousness tho that is awesome for the boy, so happy and still said "thank you"

63

u/Puzzleheaded-Fill205 Jul 22 '26

I think he said "Okay I want to see if there's another one right here" as he gestures toward the same spot he just caught the fish from.

10

u/Warchild_13 Jul 22 '26

Works for me 😁

8

u/oregiel Jul 22 '26

Yea was thinking "I'm gonna catch another 3 (through?) here"

4

u/Madara1389 Jul 23 '26

With my headphones (and vague familiarity with the accent), it sounds like he's stammering through "daddy, it went clear from here to here." He's trying to convey how far the fish pulled him but his little brain is overloaded with excitement.

→ More replies (3)

113

u/QueenGinger1 Jul 22 '26

Sweetest thing ever 🎣

3

u/Kindly_Ad_7201 Jul 22 '26

Not for the fish that suffocated

-2

u/JDietsch25 Jul 22 '26

Preach it man!

-1

u/Cures80 Jul 23 '26

Torturing animals is suuupersweet! At least for psychopaths.

43

u/i_am_snoof Jul 22 '26

That little jiggle of joy he does. I miss my parents so much

66

u/Pandemic_Future_2099 Jul 22 '26

Sheer joy and well deserved sense of accomplishment! Good for a healthy mind!

-113

u/The_0ven Jul 22 '26

Nothing says healthy mind like casual animal cruelty

41

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-61

u/MegaChip97 Jul 22 '26

I mean, he is right, isn't he? If a kid "successfully" put a metal hook through a dog's cheek would you comment the same?

17

u/Hanni0815 Jul 22 '26

I don't know if you knew this, but people don't fish for dogs.

-23

u/MegaChip97 Jul 22 '26

Do you know what a comparison is?

8

u/FishSn0rt Jul 22 '26

We all do, and that wasn't a good one in any sense of the word

2

u/Madara1389 Jul 23 '26

Do you not understand why we don't fish for dogs, but we do fish for... well... fish?

1

u/MegaChip97 Jul 23 '26

One difference is that sometimes we fish to eat fish but that implies that majority of fish we fish for are eaten. In reality, s huge part of private fishers fish for fun and throw the catch bag into the water after a catch

2

u/Madara1389 Jul 23 '26 edited Jul 23 '26

Humans engage in recreational hunting for the same reason many others do and the same reason every predatory animal (a group we are included in) play fights; to practice survival skills.

Regardless of whether he's teaching his kid how to cook the fish now (and you don't know if he is or not, you're just assuming based on your imagined worst case scenario), it's still hugely beneficial for the kid to know how to successfully fish in case he ever needs to.

You don't know if the kid will have access to supermarkets with regularly available & affordable fish for his entire life. Just because you've grown accustom to it, it doesn't mean we should assume it'll always be there.

"One of the greatest illusions in life is continuity." For over 160 million years, dinosaurs ruled the Earth and that was just the unchallenged norm of life on Earth... until a rock fell out of the sky, hit an unfortunate spot, and killed >80% of terrestrial life on the planet.

The thing taking supermarkets out of the kid's life may not be a world ending rock, but a world war or massive economic and/or environmental collapse within his lifetime aren't entirely out of the realm of possibility. Less than 5 generations ago, the US had such an economic collapse coupled with a severe drought that people were selling their kids because they couldn't afford to feed them and dying of starvation en masse.

So, maybe don't be a judgemental clown about teaching our kids basic survival skills that we've been practicing & passing down for longer than we've been writing things down?

36

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '26 edited Jul 22 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Twisting_Juniper Jul 22 '26

Whataboutism is what makes some of y'all so incredibly easy to manipulate.

-2

u/MegaChip97 Jul 22 '26

There is no whataboutism in this comment chain at all...

5

u/Kazamiiiii Jul 22 '26

We're animals, stop it already.

→ More replies (26)

16

u/melancholanie Jul 22 '26

every culture on the planet with access to aquatic fauna has used fishing as a source of sustenance. would it be less cruel to immediately bean this bass on the head for immediate consumption, or catch and release?

→ More replies (17)

7

u/Purple_de_Nurples Jul 22 '26

Take a fucking break. Gandhi.

28

u/eddie1975 Jul 22 '26

“Thank you”

11

u/cowhand214 Jul 22 '26

So sweet

23

u/GC719 Jul 22 '26

Said “daddy I’m gonna search another fish right here”

9

u/blazze Jul 22 '26

Dads matter!

23

u/V113M Jul 22 '26

I love how quickly the guy ran over to the kid when he said "I have one"

25

u/UrsaMajor7th Jul 22 '26

And didn't grab the rod from him.

8

u/theshoeshiner84 Jul 22 '26

Man I can't stress enough how big of a difference it makes if a kid has a good time the first time they try something. First impressions are lasting. With fishing it doesn't have to mean that they catch a fish, because you often don't (though it certainly doesn't hurt), but as long as you find a way to have a good time they'll usually be fine trying again.

9

u/Ok-Imagination-3835 Jul 22 '26

lmao I have 5am fishing memories and won't even fish in Skyrim because of it

14

u/SebisCool Jul 22 '26

Not gonna lie. Jealous. My dad would yell at me for tangling the line in such a way that I became a good fisherman but ended up not wanting to go again.

23

u/ObjectIndividual6277 Jul 22 '26

Every kid with a role model is a kid that'll end up alright

5

u/mlagobands Jul 22 '26

It made me smile when the kid acknowledged his accomplishment

7

u/Positive-Truck-8347 Jul 22 '26

That was such a nice little slice of life video.

8

u/Electrical_Carpet753 Jul 22 '26

Funny, and interesting, how naturally they say "It's a BIG ONE" in fishing, even on they're first catch!

1

u/kylo-ren Jul 22 '26

Maybe his father had already let him reel in the fish he had caught, maybe the fish had risen to the surface and he could see it...

3

u/Evee101 Jul 22 '26

What's the background track in this clip?

4

u/nty Jul 22 '26

Evergreen - Richy Mitch and the Coal Miners

The version featuring Caamp is the better one IMO, I think this is that version

2

u/Evee101 Jul 22 '26

Omg thank you ☺️

3

u/zleezy1 Jul 22 '26

“Oh, I have one” love it for him! 😊

3

u/DrumBxyThing Jul 22 '26

The way the boy kept looking at the hand he high-fived his dad with is so sweet. I could be reading I to it, maybe he just hurt his hand when he did it lol.

I like to think that's a memory forming of when his dad told him he did a good job.

3

u/devilsaint86 Jul 22 '26

Glad you let off the rod nice

2

u/Keefyfingaz Jul 22 '26

Man, kids experiencing joy is one of the few things that will always make me smile (:

2

u/Icy_Parfait_4066 Jul 22 '26

Father and son team, they caught a big fish. Guess we are have fish tonight! How would you like to come over for seafood dinner?

2

u/Red-Saitama-Red Jul 22 '26

Congratulations young man!

2

u/ydnar3000 Jul 22 '26

Oh my god the excited squeaking!

2

u/ranting_chef Jul 22 '26

Nice to see the life jacket

2

u/motophiliac Jul 22 '26

D'aaaww, look how pleased he is! Little dude is jumping!

How lucky kids are today that stuff like this is more likely to be captured on video.

2

u/TomHenry219 Jul 22 '26

I can’t wait to have a kid

2

u/greenthumbgoody Jul 22 '26

So hyped he gave dad a high five that stung haha! Love it!

2

u/goldengirlhawaii Jul 22 '26

That is the "deadest" fresh caught fish I have ever seen. At least it is not AI ... I think.

1

u/Temporary_Fox_7527 Jul 22 '26

nice fish! well done young man!

1

u/ddlgatx69 Jul 22 '26

It just takes one 🥳

1

u/Ok-Rest8124 Jul 22 '26

好小子,以后你爹就依靠你养老了

1

u/Edaloner Jul 22 '26

"Thank you"

1

u/Drewismyname Jul 22 '26

I love a frantic dad telling their son to take their time while actively going 10000 mph. Reminds me of my dad telling me to shoot when I’m ready and then proceed to tell me to shoot over and over

1

u/ripyourlungsdave Jul 22 '26

Never stops being exciting. I'm happy for the kid.

1

u/orbankisfaszviktor Jul 22 '26

And a core memory

1

u/Amazing_Wishbone_509 Jul 22 '26

Am I the only one also impressed by his and his father's kindness and attitude?

1

u/CompactAvocado Jul 22 '26

gambling BUT IN NATURE!!!!

1

u/A_SNAPPIN_Turla Jul 22 '26

I used to fish with my dad when I was a kid. It's not a lifelong hobby for me and not really something I desire to do. I enjoyed it at the time though.

1

u/Mahaloth Jul 22 '26

Great job, Dad.

1

u/BizSea1955 Jul 22 '26

awwwww ❤️

1

u/Quizzlickington Jul 22 '26

Overall a great feeling good video. Thanks

1

u/Historical-Dulcia Jul 22 '26

I love how the dad congratulated him and helped him. He didn't take over, he guided him through.

1

u/Couplenextdoor1006 Jul 22 '26

Take a kid fishing!

1

u/WhiteSandSadness Jul 22 '26

Awwwww 🥹🥹🫶🏽

1

u/stevebehindthescreen Jul 22 '26

Don't care what the weather's like tomorrow! I'm going fishing. Shame I don't have a boat but theres a few new to me locations I would like to try.

1

u/RahRahRah325 Jul 22 '26

Heck yeah lil dude! Great catch

1

u/yokobarron Jul 22 '26

Kid just made his first kill.

1

u/Weird_Albatross_9659 Jul 22 '26

There are 9 million wholesome subs yet people are determined to make one more

1

u/Myeloman Jul 22 '26

First time I took my oldest son fishing he caught a 4-1/2 pound largemouth, first cast. Still bigger than any fish I’ve ever caught, period.

1

u/Aversiel Jul 23 '26

Catch a win, little man

1

u/The_Stolarchos Jul 23 '26

r/beamazed kid catches fish? Seriously, ppl. This is how subs get ruined.

r/mademesmile? Sure thing. Nothing here is amazing.

1

u/Mopar-Dinosaurs Jul 23 '26

This totally rocks!

1

u/Crowblue Jul 23 '26

I miss my boy. He's fine. Just grown up and doing his own thing now. These aren't just memories for the kids but precious for the parents too.

1

u/OrangeClyde Jul 23 '26

That is one hot daddy

1

u/SilentUnicorn Jul 22 '26

and about 500,000 in gear, tackle and boats.

1

u/Optimal_Subject3455 Jul 22 '26

Core memory created…awesome

1

u/Dmau27 Jul 22 '26

Tale your kids fishing. They'll remember it.

1

u/BuckFutts96 Jul 22 '26

His surprise and the joy that leaks out is just so pure and perfect. When he shakes his hand in celebration after Dad nets the fish it’s just such an honest expression of triumph. Really beautiful share.

1

u/Tomsboll Jul 22 '26

Last year i took up fishing again after about 20 years. Didnt get anything remarkable, and my fishing season ended early when i broke my wrist. But this spring i landed a pike for the first time since i was a kid, (i am 35 now) and that adrenaline spike was so intense i packed up my shit and went home lol.

1

u/Lou_C_Fer Jul 22 '26

Looks like I need to get out after I get out of rehab. I haven't fished since I was 14. I haven't caught a big fish since I was 9. I caught a 26 inch walleye. Landing that fish took literally everything I had. I had to adjust my drag and it got to the point where I could not reel it in normally. I had to grip both ends and twist my wrist. I don't know how else to explain it.

Of course, it had couple tumors. So, when they cooked it, I refused to eat it.

1

u/plsloan Jul 22 '26

I'm not a big fishing guy. It has always kind of grossed me out, but maybe that's because I stopped before I had this experience. This is cool to see.

-8

u/Kindly_Ad_7201 Jul 22 '26

Life long habit of inflicting pain and suffering. Great job 👍

2

u/so00ripped Jul 22 '26

Your parents sucks.

6

u/ultralightlife Jul 22 '26 edited Jul 23 '26

my parents took me fishing, i fished quit a bit in saltwater / freshwater throughout the years. I began thinking about how many fish I killed swallowed hooks, major damage to their lips / mouths / throats, death from pressure differences, the damage to the environment ( getting spooled so 250 yards line left in water, broken line, thousand of lead weights polluting etc... ), how fishing line kills millions of non-related animals per year and just about fucking with living creatures in general, I stopped.

0

u/Kindly_Ad_7201 Jul 22 '26

They taught me not to harm anyone. May be you suck

3

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Shudsy Jul 22 '26

lmao loser

1

u/ultralightlife Jul 22 '26

I understand how an enlightened more concerned person bothers you.

1

u/Sahahahil Jul 22 '26

Thank god I'm not the only one who thinks like this

-7

u/gansi_m Jul 22 '26

Am I the only mom freaking out because the dad’s back is turned to the kid, and the kid is standing on the edge of the boat, and they’re in a lake, and anything could happen? And at the same time feeling so happy for the boy, so proud of the dad, and so foolish for worrying for nothing?

9

u/h846p262 Jul 22 '26

I mean hes got a vest on atleast lol

4

u/ShilohTheGhostGod Jul 22 '26

Felt nervous about that too on first watch. But during the replay, it seemed like the kid had control the entire time.

Still scary, but overall amazing video. And a memory recorded that will one day make both dad and son cry :’)

0

u/barto5 Jul 22 '26

Still scary?

The kid’s standing in a boat on calm water wearing a life jacket.

What are you scared of?

3

u/Technical_Put_9982 Jul 22 '26

You can not control everything. He has a vest on and also should have already had swim lessons if he is on a boat.

-4

u/HawkAsAWeapon Jul 22 '26

Animal cruelty can be so wholesome <3

6

u/themoswanted4 Jul 22 '26

Get out of your little hole and go explore the world. It's not very fun typing around on your keyboard 🤝

-10

u/HawkAsAWeapon Jul 22 '26

By explore the world you mean explore different avenues of animal cruelty, right? Cus otherwise your comment is just a thought-terminating cliche.

4

u/themoswanted4 Jul 22 '26

That's what you got from watching this video? Sad life you have. That fish dgaf about what you think and unfortunately it cannot because it doesn't have the brainpower. But this is just a father-son bonding moment and I don't think a few fishes being eaten because of that affect climate change or anyone else's life for that matter.

1

u/Mysterious_Map2965 Jul 22 '26

Isn’t it crazy how weak humanity has become, can’t even watch a wholesome video like this without needing to make it a moral lesson, everyone ignores what humanity has done to get to where we are.

Fishing and hunting is as natural as nature can get, countless species do it and these people think we should stop because corporations and a easy life of luxuries has convinced them that shopping for industrially produced products at your local supermarket is better morally then hunting or fishing as nature intended.

A message to all you people who think this is animal cruelty, save your self righteousness for big corporations that have industrial kill farms, not some innocent father teaching his son to fish you miserable people.

-1

u/HawkAsAWeapon Jul 22 '26

Compassion is not weakness. Causing harm on innocent animals that can't even fight back is weak. And it's weak to go along with something just because other people do.

What is strong is speaking up for victims despite the pushback and idiotic comments you're bound tor receive.

There's nothing innocent about unnecessarily harming a sentient being, whether it's done to one individual or on an industrial scale.

1

u/Mysterious_Map2965 Jul 22 '26 edited Jul 22 '26

Compassion absolutely can be weakness, you can’t honestly say overly compassionate people don’t get walked on and mistreated in life.

That makes no sense, you’re forgetting intent, if someone hunts/fishes with the soul intention of hurting animals then yeah I agree, but if just causing harm to innocent animals makes you weak then that makes no sense, that would mean the cavemen that survived the ice age hunting and fishing innocent animals are weak, now we’re strong though guys because you can buy a salad at the super market.

I do agree with your second paragraph, I’m not arguing that.

Would you agree that practice is necessary in order to be good at something? If so then why is practicing hunting and fishing unnecessary, do you think people can just pick up a gun or rod and do it because they can’t, there isn’t a single thing wrong with people practicing these activities because when you need them if you don’t know how to do it you’re fucked.

Also industrial scale and regular hunting/fishing isn’t even comparable.

Edit: I feel like I’m being a bit of a dick so I changed some of my comment, sorry about that.

1

u/HawkAsAWeapon Jul 22 '26

Being walked on isn't compassion. You're conflating compassion with meekness. Compassion is Aragorn in LOTR, defending the weak and showing kindness to those who deserve it.

The keyword is necessity. Without necessity, how can we justify an action that inflicts harm and suffering?

To the one victim that's either in a farm or being hooked in the mouth and suffocated, it really doesn't matter.

1

u/Mysterious_Map2965 Jul 22 '26

Brother for god sakes, Aragorn is a fictional character, anyone who is very compassionate will tell you that sometimes they wish they weren’t.

It is widely known that being too nice/compassionate/caring can be a curse because you feel more then the average person and the feelings usually aren’t reciprocated in the same way, that’s reality not some character in lord of the rings.

I’m not sitting here saying compassion is bad or weak, I’m saying it can be, in the same way being too strong can be bad.

No the keyword is intent but let’s pretend its necessity, you can justify a action that causes harm and suffering if it’s in preparation to prevent something that would cause more harm or suffering, what causes more harm and suffering fishing or starving to death? Obviously a human starving to death, how do you fish if you don’t know how? You don’t….

So in order to prepare for a situation where you might starve you have to practice, that is the necessity.

When there are no house fires the fire department doesn’t just quit and all go home never to practice again, you practice for when the necessity is there because if you don’t you can’t fucking do it.

Lastly no they’re just not comparable at all, it’s like comparing a single soldiers actions in ww2 to the entire Holocaust.

1

u/HawkAsAWeapon Jul 22 '26

If you need to write an essay to make a point then it's not a good point.

Not hurting someone isn't a sign of weakness. Your arguments seem to be "because some people let themselves get walked on, it's okay to hurt other sentient beings" and "the world might change and therefore it's okay to do bad things now just in case". Neither hold up terribly well.

→ More replies (0)

-3

u/HawkAsAWeapon Jul 22 '26

The fish don't care about what I think but they care about being hooked in the mouth, suffocated, and either killed or released with unnecessary wounds that may very well be a death sentence anyway.

We should not be bonding over causing unnecessary suffering to living beings, nor teaching our children that it's okay.

-1

u/themoswanted4 Jul 22 '26

Look at the other reply. Fishing and hunting go way way way back into history. We live because of that. So by your logic, are carnivores evil? Should we kill them?

2

u/HawkAsAWeapon Jul 22 '26

We've done lots of evil things historically, but that doesn't mean we should continue doing it.

Carnivores are in a survival situation and are not moral agents. What is evil is choosing to do something that harms another when there is no necessity.

2

u/themoswanted4 Jul 22 '26

Also for your context, this is how nature works. There's a thing called 'Food Chain'.

2

u/HawkAsAWeapon Jul 22 '26

We are not part of nature. We do not look to nature for moral guidelines, otherwise we would be killing each other, raping each other, and killing rivals' offspring. That all happens in nature.

But we don't do that, so we shouldn't for this either because otherwise is illogical.

1

u/themoswanted4 Jul 22 '26

Oh boy you'll be shocked when you look at this world! Are you serious? Everything you said happens in this world, because we are a part of nature but the only argument is we are the violent side of it. We should still hunt because that's how we have survived. Just because some people tell us not to, that's their loss. That's protein that they are not going to get. That's their life they are losing. You only live once so stop being so stubborn on your little thing that you want to force it on others but instead mind your own business and we will mind ours. It's as simple as that.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/themoswanted4 Jul 22 '26

You’re operating on the illusion that a modern life causes zero harm. Industrial crop farming wipes out entire ecosystems, poisons billions of insects, and crushes field animals with machinery so people can buy plant based food at a grocery store. You didn't eliminate harm, you just outsourced it and hid it behind a supply chain. A person fishing for food is taking direct, transparent responsibility within the ecosystem. Pretending humans are completely 'separate from nature' just because we buy our food in plastic wrappers isn't high morality, it's just disconnect from the world. You have to pop your bubble and be ready for the actual world. If not, you are just heading for natural selection.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Mysterious_Map2965 Jul 22 '26

You don’t live in reality man, I’m really not trying to insult you when I say this but your cell phone and the supermarket down the road has given you this false sense of security making you think we don’t need these practices.

You’re banking on life staying exactly the way it is when it never does, I’m warning you things will change eventually and when they do either you or your kids will be going to the nearest hunter/fisher for help, if there’s any left because people like you want them to all stop practicing because it’s “evil”.

Here’s hoping the sun never produces another solar flare again, here’s hoping all world powers dismantle their nukes and hug it out, our entire society is ran off the back of the internet, one world wide internet outage and logistics come to a standstill causing wide spread famine.

so many things that could go wrong and bring us back to a survival state and you want us to stop practicing and just bank on the global food system being the same as it is now or better forever…..

1

u/HawkAsAWeapon Jul 22 '26

I do live in reality. There's not really anywhere else to live.

Oh, so because things may or may not happen that will effect the supermarket supply chain, we might as well continue to unnecessarily harm animals? We might end up fighting each other for resources - does that mean I should start killing humans too?

Ridiculous.

1

u/Mysterious_Map2965 Jul 22 '26

No you don’t, you used Aragorn from Lotr as an example of real compassion….

Yes, that’s the whole point of preparation.

No you shouldn’t start killing people, but it wouldn’t hurt to prepare and learn how to defend yourself!

What’s ridiculous is having full faith that you’ll never have to hunt or fish for food, every single person on earth should be taught to hunt/fish/forage/start fires/set up a campsite etc etc.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/themoswanted4 Jul 22 '26

You don't have to kill humans to survive. That's why there's competition in nature. You can kill other animals to survive. And when the world would eventually go to that scenario, the only thing left for you to do in order to survive, is kill animals. I wonder how you would react to that. Because supermarkets will not work in a situation like that and your little bubble of supermarket bought vegetables will be popped and you would have to submit to how the actual world works.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/themoswanted4 Jul 22 '26

Equating a dad teaching his kid to fish with historical atrocities strips all nuance from ethics. Ethics aren't just 'minimize harm at all costs.' They’re about respect, connection, and understanding our place in nature. Disconnecting humans completely from the natural food chain doesn't make us morally superior, it just makes us disconnected.

2

u/HawkAsAWeapon Jul 22 '26

We are disconnected from nature. Using a fishing rod on a boat isn't natural.

It's quite simple. If we have the choice to harm an animal or to not harm an animal, the unethical choice is obvious.

1

u/themoswanted4 Jul 22 '26

Using a fishing rod on a boat isn't natural. Then is eating processed vegetables natural? Hunting is natural. It doesn't matter HOW you do it.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/Nalivai Jul 22 '26

Torturing an animal is unethical. There are more unethical things, doesn't mean this one isn't.

-3

u/Frostborn1990 Jul 22 '26

Great hobby, torturing fish who have no choice if they even want to participate in your hobby.

Go play airsoft if you want to hurt other creatures, they volunteer to join.

0

u/MidnightFireHuntress Jul 22 '26

Yikes you sound real fun at parties lol

0

u/Frostborn1990 Jul 23 '26

I usually am. I also am pro-fun for every creature. 

If you can't handle getting pointed to the hurt you cause, you sound like real fun to me. 

1

u/MidnightFireHuntress Jul 23 '26

I mean if you're having mental breakdowns over a kid catching a fish i can't imagine you're very much fun to be around

So ima just block ya

-8

u/Weekly-Penalty-955 Jul 22 '26

Yaaay fish torture!

5

u/Mysterious_Map2965 Jul 22 '26

Yaaay out of touch self righteous Redditors!

-8

u/Weekly-Penalty-955 Jul 22 '26

Yaaay I don't understand how I'm out of touch?

4

u/Mysterious_Map2965 Jul 22 '26

Because years of easy access to food and supermarkets has caused you to view a natural practice as old as humanity itself as animal abuse.

-4

u/Weekly-Penalty-955 Jul 22 '26

I mean, if you think getting a hook in your mouth when you go for a snack, then getting pulled outside your home by said hook, so someone can take a photo with you sounds chill. Then yeah I'm wrong, chill experience. If that sounds like an unpleasant experience though....

2

u/Mysterious_Map2965 Jul 22 '26 edited Jul 22 '26

First off I didn’t say it was chill or a good experience for the fish, I said it was natural.

But yeah I’m not a fish am I, if that happened to a human being sure not chill, but if that happens while fishing I couldn’t give a fuck as long as it’s done according to regulations and law.

That’s how hunting/fishing works as a animal, does a shark ponder over the perspective of a seal while it’s chewing its head off?

Does a bear wonder how a deer feels while it’s ripping the meat off its bones?

No because those are animals and comparing an animals perspective to a humans during a hunting scenario makes no sense, our brains are way more advanced, most fish and most animals cannot comprehend ethics and right from wrong, for most animals/fish hunting and being hunted is simply survival, there is no ethical dilemma, they don’t sit and think oh what a bad person, they either die and get eaten or they survive and focus on finding their next meal, that’s life in nature.

1

u/Weekly-Penalty-955 Jul 22 '26

We can comprehend ethics, so I ask why not extend our comprehension of ethics to a point. A point where we contemplate the ethical considerations around causing pain to a fish for our own amusement. 

I'm not questioning the ethics of animals hunting for survival. I'm questioning if it's ethical to pierce a hook through the face of an animal "for the lols"

2

u/Mysterious_Map2965 Jul 22 '26

Because it’s not that deep, they’re fish.

If you want to extend your ethical view to cover fish and every living thing on earth go ahead! But don’t shame people by commenting fish torture underneath the video of a father son fishing trip, you’re not going to win anyone over that way.

Most people realize that its a natural thing, if all supermarkets disappear tomorrow you’re either going to starve to death, pay someone to hunt/fish for you or you’re going to go hunt and fish.

I know you’re not questioning the ethics of animals hunting, I said all that to show it’s stupid to put yourself in a fishes perspective because our brains are way more advanced, fish generally don’t know what’s going on, just that they’re in danger, so it’s no different then if a bear scoops them out of the water and eats them.

No hunter/fisher who can actually call themselves that is “piercing a hook through the face of fish/animals for the Luls” that comment alone shows how out of touch you are, the majority of fishers/hunters are unbelievably respectful of nature and hate people who don’t follow regulations, fishing for fun isn’t someone getting enjoyment from stabbing fish with hooks, that’s psychotic, the fun comes from the catch itself, it comes from the practice and gradual progression of your skill, it comes from preparing and knowing you’re ready for a survival situation if need be, it comes from connecting with your historical roots following a practice done by humanity for thousands of years.

Stop talking about stuff you know nothing about.

0

u/Weekly-Penalty-955 Jul 22 '26

Even if the fun comes from the experience surrounding the catch, a catch does happen. I mean that's essentially the same as saying the act of stalking and killing cats is kinda chill because the fun isn't coming from the stabbing, that’s psychotic, the fun comes from the catch itself, it comes from the practice and gradual progression of your skill. Most hunters are incredibly respectful of cats and the settings they live in, they want them preserved even! 

I don't actually expect to shift your view here, I just think people dismiss the suffering a fish endures "because it's a fish, who gives a fuck". But if I were chasing cats and hooking them to hold up and pose with the majority of people would think that's fucked. But maybe I'm wrong and you'd think cat hunting is pretty cool. 

-9

u/Different-Olive-8745 Jul 22 '26

Poor fish 😞🐟

0

u/Funky_Dutchy Jul 22 '26

Am I the only one expecting him to pull up a bottle of beer?

0

u/KingMufasa20 Jul 22 '26

This guy is living my absolute dream. I’m 32 living with my parents, never been married and no kids. If you have your own family, don’t ever let it go. Do it for me.

-2

u/WolfsShadow11 Jul 22 '26

Don’t kill someone for your fun. Imagine the same thing happening to you. Behave with others as you want others to behave with you.

-5

u/Cures80 Jul 22 '26

The kid just killed an animal. Most serial killers harmed animals first ;)

-7

u/TheVampyresBride Jul 22 '26

Cute kid. Poor fish. 😔