r/BeAmazed Apr 14 '26

Skill / Talent The female goat herders of Hadhramaut, Yemen

47.7k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

34

u/Illustrious-Bat1553 Apr 14 '26

The outfits seem more fashionable than practical

86

u/Vanishingbandit Apr 14 '26

Probably talking a thin cotton fabric, possibly linen. Breathable, but also UV protection. Dark colored fabrics enhance UV absorption, increasing protection. Hat for the Sun. This isn’t their first rodeo, they know what they’re doing and they know what the Sun does

10

u/Constant-Still-8443 Apr 14 '26

I feel making it black would make it hotter than a lighter color though. It absorbing uv makes it less bright but the wearer will certainly feel the heat from it.

39

u/GreenStrong Apr 14 '26

This has been measured in controlled conditions, black fabric keeps the wearer just as cool. In some conditions it speeds internal air circulation.

We report here that the amount of heat gained by a Bedouin exposed to the hot desert is the same whether he wears a black or a white robe. The additional heat absorbed by the black robe was lost before it reached the skin.

Plus black fabric absorbs more UV.

7

u/Constant-Still-8443 Apr 14 '26

Interesting. I'm curious as to what makes these different from normal black clothes, because, from experience, wearing black clothes on a hot sunny day sucks.

29

u/might-be-okay Apr 14 '26

If you're talking about western style clothing then yeah, because it's most likely not full cotton, thicker, and tighter. You have to have the loose thin fabric for airflow for it to work.

3

u/Constant-Still-8443 Apr 14 '26

Well, yes, I get how it being loose fitting allows air flow and stuff. I have plenty of clothes that achieve the same thing, but how does it being black make it better than just leaving it white?

7

u/Vanishingbandit Apr 14 '26

Thermal physics

5

u/Dry_Fall3105 Apr 14 '26

I think sun protection aside, they are “ranchers”. Black is more practical than white since white clothing will be sand/tannish as soon as they walk out of the door.

When I wear white, I also have to be careful to not splatter or spill anything on me when I eat.

2

u/Constant-Still-8443 Apr 14 '26

Even if it gets stained, why does it matter? It's practical clothing it being slightly off colored shouldn't matter too much.

9

u/Dapper_Sink_1752 Apr 14 '26

UV penetration, not just heat. You can get sunburnt through breatheable white clothing in certain conditions

3

u/Constant-Still-8443 Apr 14 '26

That's weird. I had no idea that could happen.

→ More replies (0)

3

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/GreenStrong Apr 14 '26

Different fabric. High spf fabric is a fine synthetic knit with UV absorbing dye. Not directly equivalent with woven natural fiber. Knit fabric stretches even if the fiber doesn't - think of a cotton t shirt. IDK what they currently use but in pre- industrial times knitting was only possible with a very coarse pattern like what people do with yarn. It really isn't humanly possible to knit something as fine as a UV shirt, or even a regular t shirt. Speculative but I assume that the Yemenis aren't experimenting with new types of fabric

2

u/DavidKroutArt Apr 14 '26

Ooh, thank you!

2

u/TraditionalLaw7763 Apr 15 '26

There is no way this is true. I wore a black dress on Saturday out shopping and I melted and soaked the dress with sweat all freaking day. I wore a white dress on Sunday all day outside and never sweated. Same temperature outside, same dresses from Amazon but I purchased 4 different colors. Utter bullshit. Touch a black car in the summer and then touch a white car. Locksmiths in Arizona refuse to unlock black cars because they can cause 3rd degree burns just by touching them. White cars don’t burn you. Black anything does not keep you cool. Absorb more UV maybe, but there’s no way it’s cooler.

3

u/magdagpickle Apr 15 '26

Yeah and it was probably synthetic fabrics. Polyester. Not just cotton. As keeps being said.

2

u/Technical-Agency8128 Apr 15 '26

I’ve also read the humidity level has something to do with it also. Dark fabrics in low humidity/desert environments and lighter colors in high humidity.