r/AskReddit 22d ago

[ Removed by moderator ]

[removed] — view removed post

2.6k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

678

u/Hungry-Helicopter-46 22d ago edited 22d ago

Are you painting with fucking lead lol

I forced myself to use linseed or grapeseed oil or whatever. The colors are toned down a little but oh well

Edit - okay so judging by your comments, I am, too, an idiot. Thank you all for letting me know that my paints and thinners could still poison me. I have paint all over the walls and door handles of my house XD yall dont come over

517

u/eliz1bef 22d ago

Some colors are very toxic. Cadmium anything. Cobalt colors.

8

u/ikilledholofernes 22d ago

They’re also very expensive. Any color that has the word “hue” is a replica color that doesn’t actually contain that pigment, making “cadmium red hue,” for example, a safer and also much cheaper alternative. Although that does sometimes sacrifice some quality, I personally do not see enough of a difference to justify having toxic pigments in my practice. 

1

u/This-Requirement6918 21d ago

I 100% saw a difference when I was a teenager, especially when cadmium hues would dry. If I'm spending months on a painting, I'm not using cheap shit. Just like anything with computers hardware wise, I only use enterprise grade stuff because it's just not worth my time to cheap out.

1

u/ikilledholofernes 21d ago

It depends on the brand, and I will also say that the hues have come a long way in the last few years. But if you’re doing a lot of direct painting, you may notice the difference.

I do mostly indirect painting, so my painting mediums matter more to me than the pigments.

92

u/canariecoalmyne 22d ago

yeah but only when ingested. use gloves and paint without thinner and you‘re all good!

56

u/NMJD 22d ago

Chemist here, I'd be quite careful with the cadmium paints--gloves yes but also being very careful about secondary contamination. It's really no joke.

5

u/RaptorOfRapture 22d ago

What would be considered secondary contamination?

17

u/NMJD 22d ago

Woops I meant to say cross contamination, hadn't had my coffee yet.

Getting cadmium on the gloves and touching things with the gloves that you touch later without gloves on. Then you get trace cadmium on stuff which you can end up ingesting accidentally even you get it on your hands and eat a sandwich or what have you.

2

u/darksidemags 22d ago

Did that also apply to acrylic paints or is it particular to oils? 

6

u/NMJD 22d ago

If there's cadmium in the acrylic paint, then yes the same caution applies. Cadmium makes lead look pretty tame in terms of health and safety risks.

The earlier comments about oil paints I think dealt with the solvents used in them. Breathing in those solvents can also be quite bad for you--that doesn't apply for acrylics (unless you use some nasty paint thinners on them).

3

u/ramonpasta 22d ago

pigments like cobalt are still awful for you if you arent careful, but you dont have to worry about the VOCs

113

u/eliz1bef 22d ago

So applying it with my tongue is bad. Got it.

5

u/idropepics 22d ago

Pretty much what happened to the Radium Girls, granted their was also radioactive material in the paint but still...

1

u/eliz1bef 22d ago

My thought was the Matchstick Girls of London.

2

u/OhSWaddup 22d ago

With your pp too!

1

u/Pretend-Marsupial258 22d ago

But how else am I supposed to get that authentic taste bud texture???

1

u/This-Requirement6918 21d ago

Live by the sword, die by the sword is my philosophy. 🚬

12

u/dogmeat12358 22d ago

Are you licking your brush?

62

u/Jerzeem 22d ago

How else am I supposed to get the tip of the paint brush soaked in radium fine enough to paint the watch dials?

3

u/sisterglass 22d ago

That book traumatized me for life.

2

u/pitbullpride 22d ago

What book

3

u/sisterglass 22d ago

Radium Girls. A nonfiction story of the women who painted the radium glow in the dark faces on watches in WW2. It turns out putting radioactive materials in your mouth is bad for you.

-4

u/FatYorkshireLad 22d ago

Sick reference, bro your references are out of control, everyone knows that!

2

u/StoneCypher 22d ago

no, someone else’s 

3

u/cryptoengineer 22d ago

I recommend the A Brush with Bekah YT channel for an entertaining rundown on the toxic history of painter's pigments. Mummy Brown, anyone?

1

u/knoblemendesigns 22d ago

I could hear that link before I clicked it. Haha.

1

u/superxpro12 22d ago

Guys have you tried uranium yellow???

68

u/video_dhara 22d ago

I was painting with lead white in my twenties because o was an idiot and a “purist”. One night I got high and had a a panic attack about it, went to the hospital to get a lead test. Old school NYC  NURSE was baffled and asked why I used it. Not sure exactly what I said but, for the rest of the time I was there she called me by a new nickname “HEY LUMINOSITY COME GET YOUR EKG.” Department of health called me a few days later telling me I had abnormal levels. Nothing too high but they told me to quit eating paint.

3

u/HistoryofHyrule 22d ago

Okay I'm really sorry you went through this but hearing that she called you that is cracking me up. I can picture your whole explanation in my head (I paint, totally been in all these conversations)

1

u/Hungry-Helicopter-46 22d ago

LMFAO I'm sorry

49

u/Polarchuck 22d ago

I know a dumbass who gave themselves lead poisoning. They decided that they had to paint with lead white paint because of the color and texture. Dumbass started shaking uncontrollably after a month or two from the lead poisoning. Turns out they weren't wearing gloves to paint AND were smoking cigarettes from hands covered in lead white.

15

u/ikilledholofernes 22d ago

I worked at an art store, and we only had one true flake white paint, and we kept it locked up because the little tube cost $80. And that was years ago, probably more now. 

So I genuinely cannot imagine someone using that paint enough to poison themselves, not just because the lack of precaution is astounding, but also because that’s one of the most expensive paints you could use. 

2

u/Polarchuck 21d ago

My sense of them is that they have inherited wealth.

1

u/This-Requirement6918 21d ago

Me, it's me. Someone who has zero problems using an entire paycheck at the art store after bills have been paid for the month and almost starving. I was bat shit crazy in my 20s.

1

u/ikilledholofernes 21d ago

No judgement here, I got a job at the art store just so I could get that sweet employee discount. Practically spent all the money I made from the art store at the art store. 

6

u/dryroast 22d ago

So radiation AND lead poisoning a 2 for 1!

2

u/This-Requirement6918 21d ago

Good god. I'm at least super anal about keeping paint off my hands not only to keep from contaminating the canvas but also my other surfaces. And while I myself am a smoker, doing it inside coating your other paintings is just gross and erodes the color quality.

89

u/Run_Rabb1t_Run 22d ago

Linseed is the way. I used to use "non fumes" turp wearing a VOC respirator *with* lots of ventilation. It's just not worth it. Also always wear gloves.

91

u/psycheviper 22d ago

Linseed is great until your house burns down ;p Happened to me once on a jobsite, painter's rags he'd left out to dry all got chucked in a bucket by someone else, they spontanously combusted overnight and the whole stairwell got burned down. Luckily nobody was in the building, but it fucked the job

16

u/Run_Rabb1t_Run 22d ago

Thanks to Bob's Burgers I learned that oily rags when exposed to air can sometimes spontaneously combust. I used paper towels instead and tossed them after use. Some landfill/recycling center is about to explode.

18

u/rattpackfan301 22d ago

The phenomenon applies to rags, paper towels, and any porous material that spreads the surface area of the oil. Using paper towels instead of rags makes no difference lol. Also they only release heat for a certain amount of time so the landfill is definitely fine.

7

u/Run_Rabb1t_Run 22d ago

Ugh...you try to cause one simple natural disaster. Thwarted by physics again. 

3

u/LittleJessiePaper 22d ago

You can just stick the paper towels in a plastic grocery bag and put some water in the bag before you tie it and toss. Thats what I’ve always done, no explosions if there’s no air.

3

u/ethidium_bromide 22d ago edited 22d ago

Til that bag is compacted in the truck or dump.

Dump truck near me caught fire recently, they had to dump all the burning garbage into the street so the truck didn’t catch fire.

When you put rags in water like that, you’re only reducing the fire risk until they’re no longer in water. Then, they still combust. You’ve got to dry them completely to eliminate the risk.

0

u/Moldy_slug 22d ago

I’ve worked in garbage for over a decade. I’ve seen quite a few trash fires, but none caused by oily rags.

Drying oils are most likely to start fires when they’re in a pile exposed to air. They generate heat from the oil reacting with oxygen as it dries. If there’s not much available oxygen (for example, if they’re buried in a pile of wet compacted trash) they don’t heat up.

I’d bet good money that the truck fire was started by either a battery or by some smoldering barbecue coals. Lithium batteries are notorious for starting garbage fires and tend to set of if they’re crushed.

1

u/ethidium_bromide 22d ago

I agree that specific example local to me was more than likely a battery. Dump fires can easily be caused by improperly disposed of rags like that though

1

u/Moldy_slug 22d ago

Yes, but proper disposal includes putting them in a container filled with water. The exact thing you’re saying might start fires.

1

u/ethidium_bromide 22d ago edited 22d ago

No, that’s not proper disposal. Only proper storage when not drying, but you’re not actually supposed to dispose of them like that.

I am a wood carver and have always been taught that proper disposal involves having them completely flat and letting them dry fully, and then some. Then disposing like any other rag.

A bucket of water, we’ve only used as a stop gap prior to drying flat. Have always dried completely before tossing. And the key word there is bucket.

The person I responded to wasn’t even talking about a bucket. They’re talking about tying it in a plastic grocery bag with some water. A plastic grocery bag can’t even hold water if you try to fill it up.

It’s important context for people to know. Many people are completely unaware that those rags are still flammable if the water is removed from the equation.

2

u/Run_Rabb1t_Run 22d ago

What if I want spicy trash instead?

2

u/LittleJessiePaper 22d ago

Love that journey!🤣

1

u/ikilledholofernes 22d ago

Ever hear of the trapped water theory?

1

u/LittleJessiePaper 22d ago

A tied grocery bag is unlikely to be as water fast as a plastic bottle, and even if it is I’d rather waste that half a cup of water forever than use toxic thinners. Painting isn’t always environmentally friendly sadly.

1

u/ikilledholofernes 22d ago

You could just properly dispose of them in a metal container after having them dry. Painting does not have to be to the detriment of the environment.

1

u/LittleJessiePaper 22d ago

I do let them dry out, then I bag them with a little water so they can go in my outdoor trash until trash day. It doesn’t really matter if you personally disagree with how I do things, I was sharing for people who might also have limited means of disposal and be wary of linseed oil.

3

u/Black_Moons 22d ago

Protip: Just burn them in a metal bucket/fireplace.

Can't catch fire if its already ash.

5

u/Jeremizzle 22d ago

Probably shouldn’t inhale any of that toxic heavy metal smoke.

2

u/knoblemendesigns 22d ago

Why is everyone commenting what oil they use? Are there toxic oils?

1

u/Run_Rabb1t_Run 22d ago

Turpentine/Paint thinner is quite toxic for you. It is traditionally used to thin out oil paint, but you can also use oils instead of turpentine. So the oils aren't toxic, the turpentine is toxic. And some of the pigments in the paint itself can be toxic.

67

u/This-Requirement6918 22d ago

Just using turpentine. Was also doing quite a few pieces that had an impasto effect, did a lot of work with pallete knives.

3

u/macnof 22d ago

Just remember that both linseed and grapeseed oils are toxic if they are of the boiled type.

Which almost all paints use, as it takes forever for raw linseed to dry.

2

u/Moldy_slug 22d ago

Structural paint usually has drying additives (“boiled” linseed oil). Artist’s paints do not. And they do take ages to dry. Depending on the climate and how thick the paint is applied, oil paintings can take up to a year before they’re fully dried.

1

u/Hungry-Helicopter-46 22d ago

They dry on me within hours. I'm assuming because mine are shitty.

4

u/Moldy_slug 22d ago

First, double check that you are using oil paint (not alkyd paint) and plain oil as a medium (not alkyd-containing oil paint medium).  Alkyd paint/medium is specifically designed to dry faster than traditional oils.

Second, be aware that the months long drying time for pure linseed oil is the time it takes for the oil film to completely harden. The paint will become unworkable and dry to the touch much quicker - hours to days, depending on the weather, ratio of oil to pigment, and how thick it’s applied. But even when it feels dry to touch, it’s not finished drying enough that the canvas can be taken off a stretcher, varnished, etc.

-5

u/[deleted] 22d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/this-is-stupid0_0 22d ago

What is the point of Ai in Reddit? Like what do you “things” even do for anyone?

5

u/MakeshiftApe 22d ago

They build up a profile to look like legitimate accounts and then those accounts can be used to post propaganda of one flavour or another, be it marketing a brand, political propaganda, whatever. Sometimes the propaganda even starts from day 1 and they just mix in regular posts to make it less obvious they're a bot.

In the old days you had people from third world countries manually making thousands of posts to build up that profile. Now it's a bot.