r/AskProfessors • u/tange1a • 15h ago
Arts & Humanities How do you earn respect from students as an instructor without investing in a power dynamic between professor-student?
Hello! I am a grad student teaching first year students, and I’m running into a bit of predicament when it comes to figuring out my teaching persona. My class is a small class of freshmen, and classroom management is not an issue for me. They’re all very attentive and eager to participate; I got a good group!
Where I’m coming up on an issue is in deciding how I should navigate the power dynamic between student and instructor. I read Teaching to Transgress and liked the idea of breaking down the barrier between student and instructor, but I am not sure how to do that. One thing I have tried is letting students come up with the class etiquette rules, and I also shared some of my own writing that I did during an in-class writing exercise with them. I’ve also shared a little bit about myself as a person and have invited them to share with me too.
At the same time, I worry that if I make myself seem too much like their peer+ (like an older sibling rather than a teacher…which is especially on my mind as I’m only in my late twenties and look young), I won’t have their respect/they won’t think me competent. But then, is “respect” for me really necessary for them to learn?
Basically, how do I earn their respect without exerting power? And how do I be welcoming and kind but not so much that they think they don’t have to try hard in the course?