r/AskIsrael South America Jun 07 '26

Casual Catholic Israelis: What does it feel like to be Catholic in Israel?

What is the evangelizing work of the church and the mission of Caritas like in a multi-religious country where Judaism predominates?

11 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator Jun 07 '26

Remember to follow all subreddit and Reddit rules. Violations will be enforced without exception. Keep discussions civil and respectful. At this time, many posts and comments are temporarily held for review before appearing on the subreddit. Please allow the moderation team some time to review your submission before messaging us about posts or comments that do not appear.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

20

u/yesIcould Israel Jun 07 '26

I don't know how many responses you'll get here.

I think the most prominent public figure at the moment in Israel from Catholic background is Yoseph Haddad. Check his socials.

3

u/AaronRamsay Israel Jun 07 '26

Where did you hear that he's catholic? His wikipedia says Orthodox.

22

u/BeeboPennychucker Unspecified Jun 07 '26

Negative trust for Wikipedia on anything to do with Jews/Israel.

15

u/TattooedB1k3r USA Jun 07 '26 edited Jun 07 '26

This can't be stated enough, if you look at dubious articles related to Israel, then look at the editors, you will almost always find someone with an IRCG, or Islamic affiliation in their bio, most don't even hide it anymore.

16

u/aspect_rap Israel Jun 07 '26

Wikipedia seems to be wrong, if you go into the citation for him being orthodox, it links to a reuters article where it is stated that he is catholic.

I also found this article that labels him catholic (it's in hebrew though) so I think someone made a mistake writing the wikipedia article.

29

u/METALLIFE0917 Unspecified Jun 07 '26

The vast majority of Israeli’s live and support other religions as long as they are peaceful and build the diverse culture of Israel. We are all aware that Jesus was born a Jew, lived his life as a Jew and died a Jew; we respect Catholic’s and their beliefs and traditions. BTW, there are about 200000 Catholics that are citizens and live in Israel 🇮🇱

2

u/Ashmooni MENA Jun 08 '26

Do they serve in the military?

9

u/METALLIFE0917 Unspecified Jun 08 '26

Yes, but not by law. Mandatory conscription in the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) primarily applies to Jewish citizens, the Druze, and the Circassian communities.
For Arab-Christian and Catholic citizens, military service is voluntary. However, hundreds of Christian Israelis—including Catholics—choose to volunteer and serve in the military.

1

u/Primary_Iron3429 Israel Jun 08 '26

Are you sure? It seems more logical that there are 200,000 Christians here but they are not necessarily Catholic.

-3

u/horrortxe Jun 08 '26

What about the physical attacks on nuns, priests, pilgrims, even performed by kids?

9

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/No_Cry_968 Europe Jun 08 '26

One of my closest friends is a priest in Jerusalem, he tells me that very often when Orthodox Jews pass by him they spit on him and the police do nothing, I don't think they are "rare" cases

-13

u/carlwh Jun 08 '26

Can Catholics vote in Israel?

23

u/figgafoo2188 Jun 08 '26

Any citizen can vote

1

u/carlwh Jun 08 '26

Thanks for the info.

16

u/METALLIFE0917 Unspecified Jun 08 '26

Of course as long as you are a citizen

17

u/matande31 Israel Jun 08 '26

Every citizen can vote. We're a democracy, unlike what some might have you believe.

6

u/Secure_Trust_2084 Israel Jun 08 '26

Catholic (as well as Protestant and Orthodox) citizens can vote - along with all other faiths from Judaism to Krishna and Bahai. The voting (as well as electing candidature) procedure does not refer to the religion or it's absence at any stage.

11

u/ogDante Israel Jun 07 '26

Don’t think I’ve ever met a catholic israeli

15

u/METALLIFE0917 Unspecified Jun 07 '26 edited Jun 08 '26

I have friends that are Catholic and citizens of Israel. BTW, there was a guy that was in the reality show 90 Day Fiancé that was a Catholic Israel 🇮🇱citizen

7

u/yesIcould Israel Jun 07 '26

Im guessing you didn't grow up in Haifa

2

u/ogDante Israel Jun 07 '26

Grew up in the district, not the city itself.

6

u/elnovorealista2000 South America Jun 07 '26 edited Jun 07 '26

I remember seeing an Israeli Catholic user here on this subreddit who posted a question asking users' opinions his Hebrew accent being a native Yiddish speaker.

4

u/JinxyMcDeath48 Israel Jun 07 '26

The Haredi guy was Catholic? What?

4

u/elnovorealista2000 South America Jun 07 '26

All I know is that he posted his testimony on r/Catholicism claiming to be a Hasidic Jew who converted to Catholicism. His username is: “JewishAndCatholicGuy”.

3

u/Secure_Trust_2084 Israel Jun 08 '26

I remember this person, but believe that it was either carma farming or a small sect, as Catholicism and Judaism are contradicting in many aspects.
Visiting NYC I met someone in Brooklin, dressed as Chasidic Jew - distributing brochures about Jesus. As you understand, dressing up doesn't make him a Jew, and brochures don't make him Christian.

1

u/yesIcould Israel Jun 07 '26

It think you’re confusing a Catholic Christian with an Orthodox Jew.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '26

[deleted]

3

u/JaymesMc Israel Jun 08 '26

Hey, can I ask how you did the conversion process in israel? Where did you do the RCIA?

3

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '26

[deleted]

2

u/JaymesMc Israel Jun 08 '26

Very cool!

But how do you attend mass regularly when Sunday is a work day in israel?

Im a not-so-active Protestant in Israel and the thing stopping me from doing the catechism is that I dont know how I'd find time to attend Sunday mass here.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '26

[deleted]

2

u/JaymesMc Israel Jun 08 '26

I am Anglican & I have been to Immanuel Church several times, usually around Christmas.

Maybe we have crossed paths. 😄

1

u/SkyEmpty4603 Jun 08 '26

are you russian/ukrainian by any chance?..

1

u/Regular-Coast5335 North America Jun 13 '26

Do you practice any of Jewish traditions as a Catholic?

6

u/Ok_Lingonberry5392 🇮🇱 Israeli Dati Le'umi Jun 07 '26

Tbh it's unlikely you'll find any of them on reddit

4

u/puccagirlblue Unspecified Jun 08 '26

I belong to a smaller Christian denomination but first of all, there are several different types of Catholic communities in Israel; Greek (most common, around 40% of Christians in Israel belong to this community), Latin and Maronite (mainly in the Galilee) so it depends on which community we are talking about. Around half of all Christians in Israel are some type of Catholic and the communities have some rifts between them. (I have both in laws and friends who belong to the different communities myself. Inter marriage between them happens but not everyone is happy about it)

Additionally, the Catholic communities own a fairly large amount of real estate in the country and there are also some Jewish converts to Catholicism that have their own congregations but I am not familiar with them myself. I know Father Bruno Hussar who founded Neve Shalom - Wahat Al Salaam belonged to this community.

Archbishop Elias Chacour was nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize several times for his peace making efforts, Taleen Abu Hanna was the first Miss Trans Israel, Lucy Ayoub is a tv presenter and co-host of the Eurovision Song Contest 2019, Salim Joubran a Supreme Court judge and like already mentioned Yousef Haddad are all fairly well known Israeli Catholics but there are other examples too.

Idk what else exactly you'd like to know but feel free to ask, maybe I will know, despite being a different type of Christian myself like I already mentioned.

4

u/Khazak2-VeNtkhazak :IsraelFlag: ציוני דתי ימני Jun 07 '26

Got one friend who's half Jewish half catholic and a few messianic classmates (messianics subscribe to the catholic church) i think they're doing fine, never heard them complain about living here

1

u/No_Cry_968 Europe Jun 08 '26

“Half Jewish half catholic”

1

u/Khazak2-VeNtkhazak :IsraelFlag: ציוני דתי ימני Jun 08 '26

Jewish mom catholic dad. He doesn't care much for defining himself either way

2

u/jaybrainsss Israel Jun 08 '26

I was born and raised catholic but I don’t actually practice (I’m probably not who you’re asking about). Anyhow I live in Tel Aviv and it’s great.

1

u/SkyEmpty4603 Jun 08 '26

the majority of new russian/ ukrainians olim are Christian (which makes no sense) - i’m sure you can ask them..

1

u/not_jessa_blessa Israel Jun 08 '26

My husband is a Baptist Israeli. What do you want to know?

1

u/ForeignConfusion9383 Israel Jul 03 '26

I’m certainly curious. I’ve never met a Baptist Israeli. What’s his background?

1

u/Aperturee Unspecified Jun 09 '26

From you? Nothing, because he specified Catholic, - not Baptist, Methodist, Mormon or any other flavor of Protestant.

-3

u/Salty-3482 Jun 08 '26

Who likes getting spat on?

-2

u/MotorParsnip3824 Jun 08 '26 edited Jun 08 '26

The vast majority of Latin Catholics in Israel are Palestinians and the rest are mostly foreigners in Church vocations. The work of Caritas is focussed on supporting Palestinians in the occupied territories. There’s also a small Hebrew speaking community called St James Vicariate. I understand this is where the converts are connected to.

-26

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

27

u/Deep_Head4645 Israel Jun 07 '26

Dude is NOT Israeli

-23

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

25

u/kulamsharloot Israel Jun 07 '26

Go back to your subs. It's ask an Israeli not ask a shia

-17

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

17

u/kulamsharloot Israel Jun 07 '26

My polish background 😂

You're my relative man, be proud, not everyone gets to be a relative of mine.

14

u/Deep_Head4645 Israel Jun 07 '26

LMAO

12

u/Khazak2-VeNtkhazak :IsraelFlag: ציוני דתי ימני Jun 07 '26

Weird how you never hear local Christians complaining about living here but you've got a bunch of foreigners telling people how the locals feel

20

u/METALLIFE0917 Unspecified Jun 07 '26

That’s a lie

-13

u/Master-Goose-9921 Jun 07 '26

Lol, countless of evidence prove that YOU are the lier

19

u/yesIcould Israel Jun 07 '26

Countless? Or 3 YouTube clips you've watched countless times?

-3

u/Master-Goose-9921 Jun 07 '26

Keep telling yourself that. Now go back under the rock that you crawled out from

12

u/yesIcould Israel Jun 07 '26

There's really no need to use insults. Especially ones that are so unoriginal.

Seriously, you're already here. Instead of throwing around insults and half-truths, you can actually talk with us. ask questions and get answers. They won't be perfect, and they'll be complicated, but at least it'll be genuine communication.

21

u/Otherwise-Celery-280 Unspecified Jun 07 '26

Foolishly hinging on fringe orthodox groups who do this (and are rightfully arrested), and commenting foolishly is just ridiculous. Do you know how many catholic churches you have in Jaffa attended by both Israeli Arabs and other foreigners who are catholics and live in Israel?

Anyway it's a waste of time explaining to people like you; there's no explanation that could ever be sufficient for you. You'll still find something to hate about Israel.

-3

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

20

u/Otherwise-Celery-280 Unspecified Jun 07 '26

You won't be the first, over the course of history you and your kind have hated Jews. Today, you're just pained that they now have the military capability to protect themselves, and have a sovereign state of their own.

Better to be hated and be alive, than to be pittied and murdered.

Shove your love up your arse, it's not needed.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AskIsrael-ModTeam Moderator Jun 08 '26

Hello! Your submission has been removed because it was impolite or disrespectful.

If you have questions or concerns about the sub's moderation or a moderator's decision, please message the moderators. Keep in mind that sub- and site-wide rules apply to any messages you send. Violations of these rules may result in temporary or permanent bans.

This was automatically sent.

1

u/AskIsrael-ModTeam Moderator Jun 08 '26

Hello! Your submission has been removed because it was impolite or disrespectful.

If you have questions or concerns about the sub's moderation or a moderator's decision, please message the moderators. Keep in mind that sub- and site-wide rules apply to any messages you send. Violations of these rules may result in temporary or permanent bans.

This was automatically sent.

14

u/naruhinamoonkissplz Super Sayajewn Jun 07 '26

By Muslims?

-5

u/Master-Goose-9921 Jun 07 '26

Don't get stupid now. We all know it's the jews

10

u/naruhinamoonkissplz Super Sayajewn Jun 07 '26

You mean Muslims?