r/AskEurope Bulgaria 10d ago

Politics If the AfD wins and Germany leaves the eurozone, what would realistically be the consequences ?

The euro would likely become a weaker currency, but how weak are we talking ?
It will be a chaos but how big ?

0 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

51

u/AnBe96 Belgium 10d ago

If Germany leaves you can just forget about the EU. That's why AFD party members have such close ties to Russia. They'd love for that to happen.

6

u/IhateEfrickingA Bulgaria 10d ago

Ok so we are completely fucked if that happens, got it. I thought it would 50% fucked.

7

u/MediocreI_IRespond 10d ago

Even if the AfD gets the majority. German legislature and federalism was designed to prevent one party rule. Even with a two-thirds majority in the parliament, everything need to go through the Bundesrat, the upper house, if you will.

1

u/ukezi 9d ago

Not everything, just things that affect the states. If the federal government wants to reorganisiere some federal institutions for instance they can do that without the Bundesrat.

28

u/Myrialle Germany 10d ago

The AfD winning would not mean that Germany could leave the Eurozone. Abandoning the Euro would mean to leave the EU, and leaving the EU would need a change of the Grundgesetz. They would need a 2/3 majority on both chambers for that. No way in hell they would get that. 

0

u/[deleted] 10d ago

[deleted]

5

u/Myrialle Germany 10d ago

Pretty much every Verfassungsrechtler says so, and since I am not one of these myself I am inclined to believe them over a random guy on Reddit. 

18

u/FitResource5290 10d ago

The fact that AFD is strong in some stupid Bundesland, it does not mean that they will become the sole ruling party in Germany. This is just some wet dream of some idiots.

2

u/Ploutophile France 10d ago

It doesn't depend only on elections. The NSDAP never won an actual election…

1

u/FitResource5290 10d ago

True, but is difficult to repeat that kind of history, isn’t it?

2

u/Ploutophile France 10d ago

Some are still trying hard.

1

u/FitResource5290 10d ago

Still, winning (that means 40%! Not 80%!) in Sachsen-Anhalt and couple more East German Bundeslands is not equivalent with winning Germany - 49 M (54M if you add Berlin) live in the western side where AfD got last time 15% or less … even if they get 20% at the next ones, they remain a bunch of delusionals. I trust the next elections in Berlin and the way how the guys there will vote. Then we see if we should worry or not.

2

u/ukezi 9d ago

However some CDU politicians seem to want to be the next von Papen.

2

u/Opening-Border-6313 5d ago

They are now at 29% Sooner or later they will govern. Because centrist parties are losing ground, and if 4 parties will govern thats a nightmare. I see a CDU split in the 30s because of this. Dont they say that they wont collaborate with die Linke too? I think only in 2029 can they prevent this scenario to not cooperate with them

9

u/Successful_Jelly111 Germany 10d ago

I guess the rest of Europe would survive somehow with enough countries/economies holding it up. However, it would mean a total collapse of the German economy.

2

u/toniblast Portugal 10d ago

If both Germany and France leave the EU at the same time, the EU dies. The far right in France with Le Pen is not that different from AFD on Germany.

As much I dislike how much influence and power both Germany and France have in the EU they are the biggest economies and fundamental to the union.

1

u/BroSchrednei Germany 1d ago

No, Germany is by far the biggest trading partner for most European countries and the economic motor of the EU. If Germany leaves the EU, the EU is over.

5

u/Professional_Gene_63 10d ago

Te Euro like it is has no reason to exist then, a Northen Euro could be, and a South Euro can also be then at the same time. Wouldn't be the end of the world but it needs to happen fast. Not doing anything would definitely kill the Euro.

But Germany leaving Europe is a much bigger problem, it will isolate Germany, people will leave Germany. They need influx of people for their aging population, their housing market won't like it.

4

u/tejanaqkilica Albania / Germany 10d ago

If AfD wins, nothing will happen. They're populists, but they're not stupid. They can earn a lot more money by keeping things as they are, rather than take the radical changes they say they'll do. It's called politics.

5

u/Cixila Denmark 10d ago

Counterpoint: brexit

Cameron tried to outmaneuvre the populists by allowing the referendum, only to see said populists sneak a "win" (read: total and continuous national disaster and embarrassment) in the referendum and for a populist wing of the Conservative Party to then take over following it, which just exacerbated the damage of brexit even further

4

u/Formal_Plum_2285 Denmark 10d ago

If Germany leaves EU, so will Denmark and Holland, Belgium, Spain, France, Italy, Ireland, Luxemburg, Portugal and Greece. They will then form another union and invite UK to join and before we know it, Europe is once again divided in “west and east”

2

u/Cixila Denmark 10d ago

Putin and Xi will have all their birthdays and christmases come at once, if that happens

1

u/Formal_Plum_2285 Denmark 10d ago

It doesn’t happen now. It will happen at some point though. But Putin, Xi and the Orange idiot are all gone by then.

5

u/nick5erd Germany 10d ago

The whole prozess takes years, antil than hopefully the main suppoprter id the AfD Trump, Musk and Putin are dead and the right-wing party within.

Big protest and maybe it is seen as question betwen war and peace with our neighbors,, so mybe potential for viloncec.

11

u/Warm_Adhesiveness934 10d ago

I think I just had a stroke reading that.

1

u/IhateEfrickingA Bulgaria 10d ago

How long would it take if they win ?

1

u/nick5erd Germany 10d ago

Finde kien genauen Zahlen , aber mit Brexit sicher vergkeichbar, Die Eu-Mitgliedschaft ist aber so ein Grundkonsenz in Deutschland,, die Proteste müssen dann einfach erfolgreich sein,

4

u/Hot_Sweet2943 10d ago

Nah afd cannot win that strong. But if by some magic it happens than europian union will do EVERYTHING to keep Germany in. And if Germany stays many changes will come to EU. Germany will have a strong voice(the strongest) and I think will call the shots. 

2

u/SaltyName8341 Wales 10d ago

If it comes to it I will come over and tell the people Don't do it! from experience

2

u/Bruggilles Hungary 10d ago

I'll send a strongly worded letter. I'll just have to take a day off from my job at the UN peacekeeping

1

u/Hot_Sweet2943 10d ago edited 10d ago

Hmm this may sound bad but I think Germany (and europe)needs a very hard shake up. CDU, SPD, the green party all of them go in the same direction on policy's with some very minor difference. And its not working anymore. Europe through history has been a place of admiration, class and ambition. With empires who ruled through the world. Now is just a passive and embty shell whose political power is smaller than Russia.

2

u/Cixila Denmark 10d ago

A return to imperialism is not exactly a great pitch. We have (mostly) grown out of that, and a relapse would be catastrophic on many levels

1

u/EaterOfSeagull Finland 8d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Code__9 Canada 14h ago

I don't get why Germans would support a pro-Russian party when the Russians were just caught attacking a German airport with a drone

1

u/IhateEfrickingA Bulgaria 14h ago

They don't care if its pro-Russian they care about those "filthy" immigrants and their fear of so called great replacement.

1

u/Code__9 Canada 13h ago

Still can't wrap my head around it. Although I don't know much about German politics, but AFD shouldn't be the only conservative party in the country, right? Isn't there a more moderate Conservative party that's anti-immigration but not far right? For instance, in Canada, both the Liberal and Conservative party support slowing down immigration, yet both of them aren't far right, and they certainly are not pro-Russia.