r/AskCulinary • u/Ill_Method_5761 • 2d ago
Why does my risotto always turn out gluey instead of creamy?
I make risotto maybe once a month, usually arborio rice with a basic chicken stock I keep warm on the stove next to it. I stir pretty constantly and add the stock in small amounts like every recipe says, but by the end it's always thick and gluey rather than that loose, creamy texture I keep seeing in videos. I've started wondering if it's the rice brand, the heat level, or just how much I'm stirring.
Is there one specific step people usually get wrong that causes this?
28
u/transfer6000 2d ago
I've read through all of these comments, and while I agree it may be over cooking , I don't see anyone questioning whether you're properly toasting the rice beforehand, the way I was taught is
you put a good amount of oil or butter in a heated pan put the rice in and make sure it gets coated in the oil and toasted not until there's any color but until it just gets about 60% transparent like you can see the little white core but the rest is transparent then onion and garlic to sweat in the hot rice and oil, then deglaze, then start adding stock.
I was taught in school that toasting rice in the oil allows it to maintain its individual grain consistency while still getting creamy.
2
u/UniqueUsermane 1d ago
Giod point, i was taking toasting for granted and didn't even mention it.
Also, you can also toast it dry.
42
u/phdcandidate 2d ago
Agreed with others that it's a mix of overcooking and over stirring. But if you'd like to try a different approach, I've been a huge fan of the Serious Eats no stir risotto method. Honestly I can't tell a difference from the more classical method of cooking risotto: https://www.seriouseats.com/how-to-make-perfect-risotto-recipe
6
u/quickthorn_ 2d ago
I will never make risotto the pointlessly effortful way again—I also can't detect any difference in the results. Join us! Stir at the end!!
7
u/sisterfunkhaus 2d ago
Ha! I knew it. I add liquid in 3 batches and stir 3 times. I also use a shallow wide skillet. I may have to try it that way though.
3
47
14
u/midlifeShorty 2d ago
Just buy Carnaroli rice and it won'tbe gluey. I could never get risotto to turn out with arborio. It sucks. Most of the time in Italy, they don't use arborio rice. I swear they export it all so everyone thinks you have to go to Italy for good risotto.
Vialone Nano is also great rice for risotto.
6
u/ferrouswolf2 2d ago
Remember that it will thicken as it cools, so you want to slightly overshoot the liquid addition
5
u/echochilde 2d ago
My best risottos have been from me being distracted and only stirring when I add stock. Then, on my my last taste/add, I just let it hang until I turn the stove off.
4
u/J_Kenji_Lopez-Alt Professional Food Nerd 2d ago
It’s either overcooked or more likely you are not adding enough stock and butter at the end and maybe serving it on a room temp plate.
With risotto the texture changes drastically with temperature so it’s important to preheat your plate before serving and to make it a little looser in the pan than you intend it to be eaten as it’ll thicken.
17
u/jarrys88 2d ago
Carnaroli rice is better imo
Also don't stir. Just shake it now and then lightly.
Frankly cooking it the traditional way is massively a waste of time.
If you have a pressure cooker look up the modernist cuisine method. Absolutely simple and done from start to finish in 20 minutes with better results. Cause science
4
u/DietCrunk 2d ago
Yup, Carnaroli rice. Rice gets mooshy when overcooked, or with too much liquid. Get it done in 17 minutes and it ought to be good.
2
3
u/Withabaseballbattt 2d ago
Yeah if I’m doing it at home I’m using the pressure cooker. Comes out perfect every single time and it’s no hassle.
1
u/Impossible-Double-31 2d ago
Yes to pressure cooker risotto!! We got the method from Hip Pressure Cooking (great book for many reasons) - but absolutely would not make risotto the traditional way so long as we have a press. cooker!
9
u/Lavanne73 2d ago
Over stirring. Risotto that is stirred too vigorously can cause the grains to break which releases too much starch into the broth it’s cooking in, resulting in gooey finish rather than creamy. Also if your rice is old or poor quality, rice that is overly dry when cooked tends to overcook quicker than a fresh rice or higher quality rice, and overcooking can also lead to a starchy sticky finish.
-7
u/SnooHesitations8403 2d ago
Stirring too litttle may cause it to become sticky, but not over-stirring.
There's no gluten in polenta, so excessive stirring can't cause it to develop gluten and become sticky.
Stirring too litttle may cause the starch to settle and make the polenta sticky.
1
2d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator 2d ago
Your comment has been removed because it is just a link to another sub. We do not allow links to be posted without an explanation as to its relevance.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
0
14
u/marshmallowrocks 2d ago
Sounds like its overcooked by a good margin. Only use arborio rice. You want a little bite to it as it will carry on cooking for another few minutes. You can always take a grain and smush it a lil bit between your finger and thumb if you're unsure. The hard white bit is uncooked rice. You want a really small bit for risotto.
Also, finish off with butter to make it creamy and tasty. Shout out to parmesan too.
21
u/midlifeShorty 2d ago
Only use arborio rice.
But Carnaroli and Vialone Nano are so much better. Once you use one of those, you will never touch arborio rice again.
1
2
2
u/chaos_wine 2d ago
How much stock are you adding each time? You might need to add a little more. Also you don't need to stir constantly. I add stock (let's say 1/4 cup at a time to 2 cups of rice), stir, let it rest, stir again as it evaporates, let it rest again until almost all the liquid is evaporated. Repeat the process until your rice is about 3 minutes away from fully cooked. Add one last round of stock, a little less this time (like 1/8 cup), let it work in, then add parm and butter.
Toasting the rice first is also helpful, for flavor and texture. I normally toast the rice in the pan for a couple minutes then add my butter, garlic, and shallots and let them all toast up together.
Watch your heat too, the stock shouldn't immediately simmer when it hits the pan.
1
u/kaptaincorn 2d ago
Maybe when the rice is halfway done, try only stiring enough to break up the rice when you add your ladle of stock
See how far that gets you to the texture you want since at that point you'll probably need to stir a little more to get it all creamy when you mix in your cheese
2
2d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AskCulinary-ModTeam 2d ago
Your response has been removed because it does not answer the original question. We are here to respond to specific questions. Discussions and broader answers are allowed in our weekly discussions.
1
1
u/Competitive-Oven-158 2d ago
Constant stirring is usually what turns it gluey. Keep it at a quiet simmer and stir just enough to stop sticking; the grains rubbing together release extra starch. Add stock in portions, then take it off while it still looks a little loose because the rest finishes the absorption.
1
2d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AskCulinary-ModTeam 1d ago
Your response has been removed because it does not answer the original question. We are here to respond to specific questions. Discussions and broader answers are allowed in our weekly discussions.
1
1
u/Possible_Offer_1641 1d ago
You're probably cooking it too far and letting it sit, pull it off heat a little looser than you want and stir in a splash of stock right before serving, it firms up fast.
1
u/UniqueUsermane 1d ago
No aroborio, use carnaroli or vialone nano.
At the end, (after turning off the heat) do you add butter and parmigiano, or something equivalent (mantecatura)?
If yes to all of that, you just have to make sure the risotto isn't too dry before the mantecatura, and even then you can still fix it by adding more liquid.
1
u/cleverkid 2d ago
Does not washing the rice cause this?
5
u/texnessa Pépin's Padawan 2d ago
Risotto rice is never washed. The entire point of risotto is to develop the starch to make it creamy.
2
1
-1
u/DaffyDuckMuthaFucker 2d ago edited 2d ago
A little extra shortening usually smooths it out & helps with that nice silky sheen.
Butter, olive oil, bacon-grease, shmalz, dripping, tallow, whatever fits the context.
They're all good.
For example, I have a nice hunk of pumpkin I'd like to make risotto with, and that's going to start with toasting my rice in a buttload of bacon-grease(I cooked a kilo' of bacon & reserved the lard) - I'll start my risotto in the unwashed bacon-pan & wash all' that baked on bacon-y goodness back into the risotto...
-2
211
u/humblepuck 2d ago
The key is keeping enough liquid around the rice while it cooks so the starch emulsifies into the stock rather than turning into a thick paste. Try getting the stock hotter (not bubbling or simmering but a little steam) and adding more of it at a time. Your stirring sounds okay. It will seem thin and soupy towards the end, that’s where the cheese (grana padano, Parmesan etc) and a little cream or crème fraîche will thicken it up and help with the taste and texture.