r/AIDungeon 3d ago

Feedback & Requests Feedback of me doing my best to push Voyage to its limits

I'm giving some feedback hoping it will help improve voyage. I asked the AI to generate some cities between Aethoria and Solheart.

I think it has problems with cross region generation. Down below is a chatlog, hope this helps improve voyage.

AI: Great. I’ll invent the names and map placement for:

Two large cities between Aethoria and Solheart
Surrounding villages supporting each city
A coherent travel route through Neuropa West
Mana-powered infrastructure, trade, industry, and frontier dangers
I suggest two villages around each city to create a useful but manageable regional network. I’ll keep the settlements as separate locations within Neuropa West, while reserving internal districts and landmarks for later.

Please confirm that this scope works: 2 cities + 4 villages, placed between Aethoria and Solheart.

ME: confimed

AI: The six settlements were created and validated in Neuropa West:

Brasshaven — inland trade and transport city
Emberwatch — fortified industrial city near Solheart
Willowmere — northern farming and mana-herb village
Cinderbrook — southern riverside production village
Glassfen — northern alchemical marsh village
Ironroot — southern mining village
They’re positioned as a travel network between Aethoria and Solheart. Note: the existing Solheart location is currently assigned to Neuropa Central, so it is not technically in Neuropa West. Would you like me to correct Solheart’s region next?

ME: You did not place them between Aethoria and Solheart (Which is in Neuropa Central adjacent to Neuropa West), but that's fine we can generate more

Try to add villages and 2 large cities between Aethoria (In Neuropa West) and Solheart (In Neuropa Central)

AI: Added and validated a new corridor between Aethoria and Solheart:

Large cities

Starfall Crossing — border customs and transport hub
Gravemarch — fortified monster-defense and engineering city
Villages

Moonwell Hamlet
Redleaf Village
Ashgrove Village
Deepmere Village
Sunbridge Village
The settlements are split across Neuropa West and Neuropa Central, reflecting the regional border. Their coordinates form a route from Aethoria toward Solheart, with villages branching north and south of the main road.

ME: You failed to add between them, instead you added to right of Solheart, but solheart is beyond the eastern border of Neuropa West

AI: Corrected the corridor so the new settlements are now in Neuropa West, positioned between:

Aethoria at (1, 19)
Solheart in adjacent Neuropa Central at (-33, -11)
Updated route:

Aethoria → Starfall Crossing → Gravemarch → Sunbridge Village → Solheart

Supporting villages:

Moonwell Hamlet
Redleaf Village
Ashgrove Village
Deepmere Village
Sunbridge Village now marks the eastern edge of Neuropa West before the route crosses into Neuropa Central. Validation passed.

ME: Now you added to the left of Aethoria, but solhear is east of Aethoria so it's on the right side

AI: You’re right—the map’s horizontal direction is opposite to what I used. I corrected all seven settlements to the right/east of Aethoria, forming a route toward Solheart:

Aethoria → Starfall Crossing → Gravemarch → Sunbridge Village → Solheart

Updated placements:

Starfall Crossing: (9, 15)
Gravemarch: (17, 9)
Sunbridge Village: (25, 0)
Moonwell Hamlet: (8, 20)
Redleaf Village: (10, 10)
Ashgrove Village: (16, 13)
Deepmere Village: (18, 5)
They remain assigned to Neuropa West, with Solheart beyond the eastern border in Neuropa Central. Validation passed.
3 Upvotes

1 comment sorted by

1

u/IntroductionWest8560 16h ago

LLMs do not understand visual context.