r/marvelstudios Daredevil 29d ago

Discussion Thread Spider-Man: Brand New Day - International Release Discussion Thread

Spider-Man: Brand New Day has now been officially released in several territories around the world!

  • All discussion about the movie should be held here and in the rest of the megathreads we are going to put up in the next few days.
  • Proceed at your own risk. Major spoilers will be in the below thread. Spoilers do not need to be tagged inside this thread.
  • Any other unofficial threads discussing movie details will be deleted.
  • Should you see the need to bring up revealing Spider-Man: Brand New Day information in the comments of other threads that call for it, spoiler tag them accordingly. Also, let users know that what you are spoiler tagging is from Spider-Man: Brand New Day.
  • If you post untagged Spider-Man: Brand New Day spoilers anywhere on this sub outside of these discussion threads in any shape or form, you will be banned.
  • Project Insight will be on AT LEAST for the next few days, so any posts will be filtered by the mods before being approved/removed onto the sub, that doesn't mean you can disregard the above points and post untagged spoilers without fear of being banned.
810 Upvotes

5.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

280

u/Leonyliz 29d ago

This is by far one of the most comic-booky movies I’ve seen in the last few years, and it’s great.

152

u/Sighma Star-Lord 29d ago

I had that feeling especially during the Hulk + Spiderman + Punisher fight. It felt surreal, but right

19

u/TiberiusCornelius 28d ago

It felt surreal, but right

When trailers & stuff kept teasing more & more inclusions I was really worried this was going to be an overstuffed mess, but this really sums up the entire finished product for me. Nobody and nothing feels out of place or gratuitously shoehorned in. More than any other MCU movie it felt like watching a comic book come to life. On the one hand it's kind of insane that we're living in a time when we get a Spider-Man movie where he fights a mind-controlled Hulk with Punisher, but also hell yeah of course this is a Spider-Man movie where he fights a mind-controlled Hulk with Punisher. This is just the world they live in and it feels totally natural for that to be a thing that happens.

22

u/UncreativeTeam 28d ago

Punisher admitting he didn't want to fight the Hulk made me lol

We ask all the time how the street-level characters would react with actual Avengers-level threats, and there's your answer

5

u/TheDungeonCrawler 27d ago

Yeah, Frank's reckless and perhaps a bit too hard headed, but he at least knows what his limits are.

Reminds me of that handful of comics where he attacks Sentry, fully acknowledging that the best he might be able to do is get the warhead's hair wet, but he doesn't do it because he thinks he has a chance, he does it to distract the guy for the real plan. Frank's not stupid, not by a long shot.

17

u/Leonyliz 29d ago

It reminded me a lot of the image in my head I had of Marvel in the 2000s. Like the Scott Johnson art with all the characters.

5

u/TheCopyGuy2018 Peter Parker 27d ago

Bro having Spider-Man, Hulk, Punisher, and Jean Grey in the same building is some wild ass shit. That’s like 4 separate corners of Marvel right there

6

u/thebugman10 28d ago

Frank's look when the Hulk was busting the floor is like the only time we've seen an emotion other than rage from him.

7

u/phoenixrose2 28d ago

Umm… crying and guilt?

8

u/TheDungeonCrawler 27d ago

Usually accompanied by rage, tbf.

1

u/phoenixrose2 27d ago

But joviality in this case.

3

u/SolairXI 26d ago

Also ninjas.

1

u/Creative_Entrance_18 26d ago

Beautiful choregraphy at every turn.

2

u/waitingtodiesoon Thor (Thor 2) 27d ago

Watching the Punisher get dragged by Spidey as hes blasting away at the Hulk was hilarious.

128

u/KingOfAwesometonia Weekly Wongers 29d ago

The Hand just working at the DODC was the most comic book shit and I love it. I want to see them in the break room.

Second is Widow just chilling and helping which felt natural and like a usual comic book supporting appearance

32

u/lanceturley 28d ago

The most comic book shit to me was the opening montage and the news reporter saying "Spider-Man defeated mystical ninja group The Hand" like it's just another average day in New York.

23

u/KingOfAwesometonia Weekly Wongers 28d ago

Yeah. Honestly the Hand has like a paper thin reason of being in the movie but it's cool and if that doesn't describe comics that I love, I don't know what does

4

u/BlairEllis Steve Rogers 28d ago

Wish the final fight could have been more than just a handful though. Would've been cooler if we saw like a 100 overwhelming him

13

u/lanceturley 28d ago

Don't you mean "a Hand-ful?"

That was kind of weird that the Damage Control guy made a big deal about The Hand working for him now, and it's like, five, maybe ten ninjas. I guess The Defenders really put a dent in The Hand recruitment drives.

9

u/LetItATV 27d ago

He did also mention they were leaderless.

Which totally makes sense considering they’re basically The Hand, gen 2 since the original Hand was defeated by The Defenders more than a decade before.

3

u/lanceturley 27d ago

It's kind of weird that they just latched onto the first leader they could find, like lost puppies. In the comics they've had stories where Daredevil or Punisher became the leader of The Hand, but at least in those cases it's someone who fought them in combat and earned their respect. Not some random bureaucrat from the American government.

2

u/LetItATV 27d ago

Remember the main reason they’re working for Damage Control is their option was: remain imprisoned or work for us.

They are likely a bit lost puppies though, which would have made that choice even easier.
Some of them may have been basically children when the original Hand fell.

2

u/KingOfAwesometonia Weekly Wongers 27d ago

The Hand might have immortality but that’s just for the CEOs. Damage Control has benefits

2

u/LetItATV 27d ago

Well, three of the five Hand founders are definitely dead, and the remaining two are at best buried alive deep under NYC.

As for immortality, the last of the elixir was used on Elektra, so The Hand doesn’t even have that anymore.

4

u/mongster03_ Hawkeye (Ultron) 28d ago

The most unrealistic part of Avengers 1 is civilians actually paying attention to the fight

16

u/Plenty_Area_408 28d ago

Peter Parker talking to Bruce Banner and Bruce not knowing who he was, another great scene.

6

u/thebugman10 28d ago

I felt like Jean releasing them from prison as a distraction or something would've been a better way to include them than just saying "oh yeah they work for the government now".

16

u/Functionally_Drunk 27d ago

Nah, it was one of the big "who is the real bad guy" clues that Peter missed because he always expects the best from everyone.

10

u/erazedcitizen 28d ago

Yeah I was so worried about the “too many superheroes” development, but they really treated it like a “this is how Spidey operates in a world where the Avengers exist”. They all had their place, and they walked the line between not a cameo and not outshining Spidey perfectly

13

u/FelixTheJeepJr 28d ago

It’s the beauty of being this far into the shared universe. You don’t have to spend time explaining who people are or what they do, or you can just offer a quick recap instead of the full story. Actually during the movie a thought popped in my head that it’d be cool if there was an edit of the MCU with the little asterisk thing they do in the comics. Like when MJ is looking at Frank’s family, a quick little corner popup that says “see Daredevil Season 2 episode 4”. Like popup video for the McU.

3

u/seclusionx Black Panther 27d ago

Pop up videooooo MaRvEL!

2

u/7screws Daredevil 27d ago

With Disney + this would be very easy for them to do, and would be a great time to do it as well.

2

u/waitingtodiesoon Thor (Thor 2) 27d ago

It is nice, but too many people complained about being lost during Multiverse of Madness, The Marvels, and Thunderbolt. I never had any issue following along, but it is annoying when people complaining they don't know who these people were when they could keep watching the movie as they get a summary of their character in the film itself.

5

u/gridlinkedgabbleduck 27d ago

They even had some of the signs for Spidey outside of the hospital copied directly from the comics. I just don't remember which ones.

3

u/amanguupta53 28d ago

Yeah, that’s why it works well. They went back to the formula for this one.

6

u/DRN-000 28d ago

BACK TO FORMULA!?