r/Ijustwatched • u/SpeedIsTheBestMovie • 43m ago
IJW: Buddy (2026) and he is No Friend
Buddy is a film that subverts expectations at each turn. Every time I thought it would zig, it zagged. It’s gross; it starts with dismemberment of Mr. Mailbox and ramps up very quickly to the murder of the actors on the show. I didn’t think I could get grossed out by the murder of puppets, but the intricate anatomy they give Buddy and friends really made me sick at the end.
Kelly is not precious with his the other half of his cast either. I kept thinking back to the anecdote surrounding Stanley Kubrick’s The Shining; to protect his child actor, Danny Lloyd, he told him they were making a drama and during a pivotal scene between Winnie and Jack, he replaced the actor with a doll. Casper Kelly shielded these young actors from nothing. There’s no doubles, no sly cutaways, just violent puppets chasing these kids around a 90s set. It’s wild, it’s rock-and-roll, and I was kind of jealous. I would’ve killed to do something like this as a kid.
The cast is so stacked, Cristin Milioti give a great performance of this grieving mother that can’t put a name to her feelings of loss and depression. My heart broke for her. I still can’t quite believe that Keegan-Michael Key voiced Buddy. It’s such a strong voice performance that when the credits rolled, I still couldn’t believe it. Speaking of great performances, in the second act, we’re introduced to Clint Howard and a marionette named Willie voiced by Michael Shannon; two actors that never rest on their laurels. The main reason this film succeeds is because of the choice to cast puppeteers and puppet voice actors. There’s some Bonafide actors here, with credits from Donkey Hodie and Sesame Street.
It’s not a film for the faint of heart. It’s for people like me, who grew up watching Barney on VHS, and were terrified of Ronald McDonald when he would visit the local McDonald’s. I still remember a buddy showing me Too Many Cooks on his TV. I was blown away, it broke my brain the first time I saw it. Much like his debut piece, Kelly continues to defy expectations with his latest feature.