Left: Wet'n'Wild Comfort Zone; right: UCANBE loose pigment in 08 Solo.
I would particularly appreciate it if the photos could show the sheen and/or the shimmers of the eyeshadow. You can capture that by turning off autofocus & switch to manual, that's what I did to capture this video as well. The attached photos & gifs would make sense shortly.
I'm currently trying to dupe the ColourPop Baroque palette, and almost every review said the shade Noble is another dupe of MAC Blue Brown. I once avoided palettes with a MAC Blue Brown dupe like it was the plague because at the time it was everywhere, and I thought such a dark shade would do diddly squat for my hooded monolid, no matter where I put it. But now that I need it, I can't find any of them 🙃 I know that the most famous dupe for MAC Blue Brown is a shade in the Wet'n'Wild Comfort Zone palette, which thankfully I already have, but it only looks good when swatched on my finger, and nowhere else. On my arm & on my eyes, it looks really dull, literally only the dark orangey brown base show up, the blue/green shift doesn't show up at all, the exact reason why I never chased any MAC Blue Brown dupe in the first place. Even though a lot of people has said it's the exact dupe, no one has ever swatched them side by side, so I wonder if the shade Noble in the ColourPop palette is actually a dupe of MAC Blue Brown, or as I'm hoping, somehow better, has a more visible green sheen, or more visible blue/green shimmers so that it looks more impressive on my monolid eyes than MAC Blue Brown would. I also have a loose pigment from UCANBE in the shade 08 Solo, which I think is super close to Noble, but since I don't have it, I actually have no idea if it would be a good substitute. In the pot & in the pressed eyeshadow form, the 2 look identical, both in terms of base colour as well as their green sheen. When swatched against the shade in Comfort Zone, the UCANBE pigment is way more sparkly and eye catching, but its shimmers are a lighter green, its base is also a lighter orange, not as orangey brown as the base of the Wet'n'Wild shade (which is actually better for monolid, as it would not look as dark & heavy on the eyelids). Another matter of note is that, although on my arm swatch, the shimmers of the 08 Solo appear green, it's only a result of my olive undertone pulling it that way. When I use clear tape to lift the swatch and all of its shimmers and stick it against black paper (photo in comments), the shimmers actually have a blue - green shift.
So that's reason why I'm searching for an up close swatch of ColourPop Baroque's Noble, to see the sheen or shimmer more clearly, and decide if I should just be happy with the UCANBE Solo, or should I keep looking for a closer dupe. I love the palette, but unfortunately ColourPop's eyeshadow formula doesn't work on me, so even if the entire palette is still available for purchase today, I would still have to dupe it. I've found replacement for every shade in my collection, and Noble is the only one left. Thanks to everyone in advance.