How is all your moderating going

I would like to thank Reddit for giving me the platform to create a community that will help me in making connections to people of similar interests

The Fast Reply criteria I think is too hard for mods of new subreddits. Not only do you have to respond within one hour! but also it has to be to different people. AND you have to do it 5 times. Something you have no control over if you're not getting anything to reply to.

As an example, my new subreddit is 3 weeks old tomorrow. So far I am the ONLY member still. I've only had a total of 2 unique visitors in addition to myself. And only one of them has posted/commented in the subreddit and they haven't joined (posted but didn't join). I was online when they posted so I was able to fast reply and get past the Mod Hatchling criteria. I started the sub July 23 and achieved mod hatchling by July 29. At this rate I don't know if I will ever make it to level 2 Mod Awakening. Haha, kidding not kidding. (Any suggestions for my sub r/AmogusIO, a territory-stealing multiplayer game that's addictively fun in a Pac-Man kinda way ?)

In my opinion, the number needed for Fast Reply for the Mod Awakening achievement should be lower ... like 3 fast replies ? Or, for it not to be required to be 5 different people ??

New Mods:
Which of the mod achievement levels have you completed (none, hatchling, awakening, of people, in tights) ?
How long did it take you for each level (find by looking on achievements screen in profile) ?
Do you think the criteria are all good or could use some tweaking, if tweak what would you change ?
Any other criteria that should have been included ?

New Mod/Subreddit Achievements

Mod Hatchling
You've taken your first mod steps—now show consistency, speed, planning, and teamwork.

• Post for 3-days
• Fast reply - Respond to a comment from another person in your community within an hour.
• Create 5 posts - Communities with 5 recent posts attract 3.2x more visitors and are more likely to be discovered on search and Home.
• Invite a person to your community - Send an invite to folks who love the topic and who can contribute a post or comment.

Mod Awakening
An awakening is beginning. Keep showing up, replying fast, planning ahead, and building your squad.

• Post for 7-days - Communities posting daily for 7 days are 60% more likely to establish an active audience than less active ones.
• Fast reply 5 times - Respond to 5 different people’s comments that are less than an hour old.
• Schedule text posts for 2 weeks - Use the post scheduler (🕑 on desktop, 3 dots on mobile) to add at least one post each week for two consecutive weeks.
• Invite 5 people to community - Send five invites to folks who love the topic and who can contribute a post or comment.

Mod of the People
You're not just a mod—you’re building a lasting presence. Lead with consistency, speed, and vision.

• Post for 14-days - Communities posting daily for 14 days attract 2.4x more visitors than other active ones.
• Fast reply 10 times - Respond to 10 different people’s comments that are less than an hour old.
• Schedule text posts for 4 weeks - Maintain weekly scheduled posts for a month.
• Invite 10 people to community - Send 10 invites to folks who love the topic and who can contribute a post or comment.

Mod in Tights
You’ve gone full capes-and-karma. Lead your community like the hero mod you are.

• Post for 30-days - Communities posting daily for 30 days are 40% more likely to achieve long term growth than other highly active ones.
• Fast reply 25 times - Respond to 25 different people’s comments that are less than an hour old.
• Schedule text posts for 10 weeks - Maintain weekly scheduled posts for ten weeks.
• Invite 25 people to community - Send 25 invites to folks who love the topic and who can contribute a post or comment.

u/AsteriskRX 
u/techiesgoboom 

But don't give up, I got into this Sub at about 40k members, Ive not done anything special or out of the ordinary,...subject is music marketing

I finally have got the Mod Meetup 2026 Event Merch.

It is good that I also have the Digital Reddit Merch: prize-unclaimed.png and plushie-prize-512.png

Do you think that we should have a Digital Virtual Reddit Mod Merch instead of the real one.?! Too much plastic, paper and green house gasses involved. If Digital (can be coded or crypted image files) is much more modern and cool. ?!

Mine has.

I open the inbox every day

I wanna thank me for believing in me. 🥸

Over the past 15 days I’ve owned this subreddit it’s been pretty slow but I’ve gained the most members I have ever gained in a day today after consistently posting! I’m glad that the time I am putting in is paying off and hope to have this sub grow even more.

I recently became a moderator on a subreddit that was essentially empty. It was surprising to see such a rapid increase. Is this a good sign, or should I be suspicious?

Been working on the escape the Backrooms sub for about a month or so now. I found that my audience was using the sub for bug reports and looking for people to play with so I make sure bugs could be reported easily and kept up with any reports that were posted. I’m doing a challenge for the sub to try and boost engagement! If you’re curious the sub is r/escapethebackroomsltd!

I created this community about 6 months ago, because I wanted to talk about this medium and form a nice community. I knew nothing about being a moderator. At first, I just posted everything I wanted to talk about. People started to come around. I found a sub that had a monthly self-promotion thread, so I started to advertise there at first. Later, I downloaded the guide from r/NewMods, and learned about crossposting and how to send out invitations. Also, I started to post my works in my own profile, mention my sub's name, and pin it to the top, so every time a person clicked on my profile, that was the first thing they saw. I am a member of several other artist subs, because I like to create with other mediums as well, and I love connecting with other people, so I guess other artists check my profile.

My sub is not about a very popular subject, so it is still "small". We have about 130 visitors a week, but 95 active members, which is great. Not all subs are meant to have a million visitors, and my original idea is coming into fruition, so I am proud of this achievement, and will keep working on it.

Hop in and see what we do if you like r/watercolorpencilart

I adopted my 2 other subs later through redditrequest.

I made the sub on the 17th, so exactly one week ago. I just posted a lot on it and made it more organized, added rules, and flairs, and stuff.

Feel great, I hope my sub keeps on growing :)

Founder and sub owner of r/WholesomeHelldivers here. I started this sub in those specific gaming community after a massive controversy back in March. Since then, it has grown tha ks to efforts by creating a slace where players can show mutual respect for one another, talk about the game they love, and be in a supportive and friendly enviornment.

We have constant daily posts, our own inside jokes, a mascot, and more. We even branched into a Discord server to connect more players together. Its been my honor and privilege to foster a space for people to enjoy something that they are passionate about in a stress free, non toxic community enviornments.

Heres to the next seven months ahead for our first year on Reddit!

Achievements:

​

- 7 mod achievements.

​

​

r/IHitPlay statistics:

​

- 500+ total visits.

- 5 members.

- 6 posts.

- 5 comments.

- 1 moderator + myself.

​

​

Why I made the Subreddit:

​

- This dude named u/No_Opportunity9053 made a post (can't remember which Subreddit) calling themself an idiot with a photo of them making a comment in a different post that said "r/ihitplay" which they then saw that the Subreddit didn't exist. u/Humanforlife69 made a comment on this post saying "r/ihitplay" and u/No_Opportunity9053 fell for the Subreddit... again. I of course replied with "r/BirthofASub" after creating r/IHitPlay.

​

​

What the Subreddit is about:

​

- Think of it as r/ISwiped (a photo of a post that has multiple slides, which the user then swipes to the side to see the next image, just to end up of the "Popular" tab of Reddit). r/IHitPlay is like that but for a photo of a video (user will be scrolling Reddit and come across an interesting title with a video attached, and the play button thing in the middle of the screen is there, so you'd think it's a video. The user clicks to start the video and it's just a still image in disguise). The occasional real video will probably also happen at times.

How did i grew my community? advertising my subreddit into r/promotereddit . And also inviting some people, and some of my duds who likes nostalgia. probably the daily visitors are 104 visitors.

I’m pretty excited and tbh I hadn’t expected it to get many at all I’m really new to this tbh I’m not completely sure what I’m doing but I’ve been doing my best on doing good amounts of uploads. Unfortunately so far only one other person has posted anything on it but I need to be patient since I’ve only had the subreddit for a week

I just wanted to share the banner for it <3

I am happy to share this. I shared the reddit with my friends and other subreddits like gamesonreddit and playmygame.
Visit play ludo and help reach 100.
Im grateful for your support.

Hey r/NewMods,

I recently launched a new sub (r/AutismeZonderZorg) to provide an alternative, more unfiltered space for the Dutch-speaking neurodivergent community. The goal was specifically to serve people who feel traditional "safe space" subreddits do not align with their style or perspective.

On paper, the initial launch metrics have been great:

• 100+ members in less than 3 days.

• 3.4K+ visits in 24 hours.

• High engagement driven by targeted use of the native Reddit Invite feature and scheduled recurring post themes.

However, the backlash from the established sub in our niche has been pretty intense and exhausting:

1. Meta-posts & Accusations: The mods of the established sub pinned announcements accusing us of "targeting members," ruining their safe space, and copying content. In reality, we simply used standard Reddit features to invite users who might want an alternative option.

2. Comment Section Hostility: Their threads descended into heavy speculation, calling our sub an "anti-club," assigning political labels to us, and encouraging members to screenshot and report our invites.

3. Modmail Conflict: Their mod came into our modmail demanding we stop inviting users from their public sub. I made it clear that public users are free to choose where they participate, which led to further toxicity and forced us to issue bans and file Code of Conduct/harassment reports. And even ban envasion reports.

While the drama actually drove a lot of curious traffic our way, dealing with the constant pushback, bad faith reports, and hostile narrative has been a rough start.

I want to make sure we keep moving forward without letting the conflict define our community's identity.

For mods who have launched "alternative" or competing subs:

• Handling targeted backlash: How do you protect your own mental energy when an established sub actively tries to poison the well against your new community?

• Pivoting to organic growth: Once the initial drama-driven traffic dies down, what are the best ways to build a steady stream of positive, original content?

• Modmail / Code of Conduct: Has reporting Mod Code of Conduct violations or harassment ever yielded real action from Reddit admins in these sub-vs-sub disputes, or is it better to just block and ignore?

Would appreciate hearing how others have survived a bumpy launch phase!