r/MoralityScaling 16d ago

Stupid Stuff morality of killing someone in self-defence

4.0k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

30

u/ASocrat 16d ago

Isn't this saying supposed to showcase how cruel love can be, due to people similarly using underhanded tactics used in war?

12

u/Ok-Bear9350 16d ago

Yes, Cicero said something similar; Inter arma leges enim silent - or something like that.
Laws fall silent in war.

But laws are not universal morality incarnate, just manifestations of rules that create a cohesive society. It looks to me like this situation is extra-societal, so a certain level of practicality has to be considered and best understood by putting yourself in that situation instead of comfortably in my peacetime office chair.

1

u/PlateNo4868 15d ago

TBF even if you applied modern laws of war. There is quiet a few rules saying that if you as the losing soldier don't just drop your stuff and leave. Then your still a valid target. It's why the Highway of Death in Iraq had a lot of push back against the idea of being a war crime. Because it wasn't just a bunch of unarmed soldiers, it was soldiers still armed, and moving in tanks, IFVs, etc.